> LSE Media Group event
> 'Under the Covers'
> The democratisation of knowledge or copyright rip-off?
>
> Date: Thursday 25th May
> Time: 5.30pm-7.00pm (with post-debate drinks after)
> Venue: Stationers Hall, Ave Maria Lane, London EC4M 7DD

Just come back from it. 

A somewhat imbalanced panel of IP lawyers, publishing industry advocates, an 
Oxford academic, and a representative from Amazon.  Google (as usual) had 
declined to participate. Most of debate took the form of haranguing Amazon 
about their "Look Inside" feature and other things. I found it odd that for 
about the first half hour or so, nobody seemed to make any distinction 
between works in and out of copyright until a lawyer in the audience stood up 
and told them to.

Everyone on the panel seemed to be "worried" or somehow "concerned" about 
something slightly different, but didn't seem to want to elaborate very much 
- the chair was pretty poor. The Oxford academic was worried about the 
Bodleian's deal with Google - lack of open standards and whether Google would 
be around in 200 years time. Fair enough I suppose, if a little bit late to 
be having such misgivings. The publishers were worried about "control," and 
one in particular about specific cases of IPR infringement involving stuff 
they found on Google Images (Zzzzz). 

So - not a very good debate from my point of view, but then I'd had a bit of a 
tiring day and the acoustics were really awful so I may have missed some 
stuff. 

Jonathan



_______________________________________________
fc-uk-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/fc-uk-discuss

Reply via email to