This is a non-issue from a free culture perspective - EXCEPT if Murdoch
attempts to subsequently countermand the wishes of a freeculturalist who
submitted work to MySpace.

If I submit my art as free culture to MySpace, Murdoch is just as free as
anyone else to make money from my work. What he is not privileged to do is
contravene my moral rights or restrict the freedoms of anyone else who
obtains legitimate copies or derivatives of my work.

For example, Murdoch et al can sell a copy or derivative of my work, but he
cannot stop the purchasor of that copy subsequently making reproductions or
derivatives of their own. Moreover, if Murdoch sells the work I have freely
submitted to his site, he does not owe me any royalties, nor do any of the
other subscribers - who are also free to sell my work.

This should define any demonstration by MySpace subscribers who also
subscribe to the ideals of free culture - and help avoid unwitting
hypocrisy.

The moment Murdoch 'crosses the line' is when he sues someone for making a
copy or derivative of a legitimately obtained work originally submitted to
MySpace by a free culturalist.

_______________________________________________
fc-uk-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.okfn.org/mailman/listinfo/fc-uk-discuss

Reply via email to