SPOILER SPACE S P O I L E R S P O I L E R Y O U It is an inconsistency - because based on the way they had to transport - it had to be pug there. In chapter 4, You write about how Pug is limited to transport by line of sight, and even how he faces more difficulties in transporting two others because he is tired from their travels. Where Magnus obviously has an easier time. The entire incident would need a re-write beyond switching names. Not the least of which they speak about Pug not being one of their favorite people and his understanding that. Then of course in Chapter 15 - Amirantha and Sandreena speak to Pug as if he has no knowledge.
Larry On Tue, Jan 31, 2012 at 3:28 AM, Martijn Bouman <[email protected]> wrote: > I do not understand this fully. In chapter 4 Pug has some adventure, and > meets someone. > In chapter 15 he gets told by Sandreena and Amirantha who he met, and acts as > if he never met these people. > > So my guess was, that chapter 4's Pug is in fact supposed to be Magnus. Then > chapter 15 would make sense. > > > > ________________________________ > > Van: [email protected] namens Raymond E. Feist > Verzonden: di 31-1-2012 9:15 > Aan: feistfans-l > Onderwerp: Re: Huge inconsistency in ACI. > > > > On Jan 30, 2012, at 11:52 PM, Martijn Bouman wrote: > > > I cant seem to figure something out, and i dont want to give away > spoilers, but i think i found a problem in the book. Maybe its only in the > digital edition ? > > Its not so much a huge inconsitency, its a matter of having names > mixed up for an entire chapter. > > For anyone who have read it already, chapter 4 and chapter 15 dont add > up together. > > Did i miss something in my quick reading of the book, or are the names > really wrong in the whole of chapter 4 ? > > > > No, but the last edit missed a deleted chapter at the end of Chapter 6 which > explains why there seems to have been a transformation from Pug to Magnus. I > was told it had been fixed and the missing paragraph returned to the every > end of the chapter. We're not sure how it got lost, save it was the last one > and was alone on a page and perhaps that page got deleted or fell out during > galley setup. In any event, it should be at the end of Chapter six. If > someone with the hardcover could tell me if at the end of that chapter > there's a bit of Pug's internal dialogue where he postpones returning to the > island at once and sends word to Magnus to keep working with Sandreena and > Amirantha, then I can communicate to Harper what's what. Thanks in advance. > > Best, R.E.F. > > ---- > www.crydee.com <http://www.crydee.com/> > > Never attribute to malice what can satisfactorily be explained away by > stupidity. > > > > > -- If you want to take the island, then burn your boats. With absolute commitment come the insights that create real victory. -Tony Robbins
