Honestly, there is always a lag due to the fact that people respond to a post before reading the other twenty-five posts that come in. That is why I usually will read the comments that come after the violation before saying anything, and will usually find that whatever comment is necessary has already been made. It would in fact be an excellent policy for list denizens to see whether the offender has already been admonished prior to typing, but most people react first and read-on later.
Still, unless the person who broke the rules tries to defend themselves (usually vociferously), and unless three other people jump in trying to defend the person who broke the rules which they themselves have not read, the chorus of condemnation will generally die down within a day, and everyone can move happily along with their lives. Best, David ps. When I referred to the list owner I was referring to Dan Lorey (whose name escaped me when I was typing), not Mr. Feist. On Apr 22, 2012, at 9:25 AM, John Buttimer wrote: > Except when people do do hat and the badgering continues anyways. > > Sent from my iPhone > > On Apr 22, 2012, at 8:16 AM, David Marcus <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Fact is it s a mailing list for Mr. Feist's books that is governed by rules >> established by Mr. Feist, the owner of the list, and developed over many >> years to avoid unpleasantness. I am constantly amazed at the inability of >> many visitors who come to this list to follow the rules. I am even more >> amazed by the reaction of certain individuals when they are corrected for >> having violated the rules and asked not to do so again. We could probably >> cut down traffic on the list by 25% if when someone broke a rule and was >> corrected, the response was mature and gracious...something on the order of >> "I'm sorry...I didn't realize. I won't do that again." >> >> Best, >> David >> >> On Apr 22, 2012, at 8:07 AM, Jeff C Goodhall wrote: >> >>> FACT is YOU ALL need to get a fecking life or work harder! It's a mailing >>> list for books, end of. >>> ----- Original Message ----- >>> From: Ray Chiang >>> To: feistfans-l >>> Sent: Saturday, April 21, 2012 7:18 PM >>> Subject: Re: Feistfans-l list rules 20-April-2012 - Goodbye and Good night! >>> >>> On 4/21/2012 9:16 AM, John Buttimer wrote: >>>> >>>> Well said well said! >>>> >>>> On Apr 21, 2012, at 8:34 AM, [email protected] wrote: >>>> >>>>> >>>>> I agree as well. I usually only have one thing to say every so often. As >>>>> the overlord says below questioning the rules or the status-quo is >>>>> perceived by a bunch on here that it is a bad thing. But think how our >>>>> country would be if we didn't question the rules of the British rules and >>>>> taxation. (Sorry to the British fans here - hehe) I am not one to just >>>>> believe the rules are perfect and not question them. No one is >>>>> infallible, not the rule creators, Ray or anyone else. Opinion is a fine >>>>> edged blade and should be welcomed by any that want to give it. Pointing >>>>> out the issues, and getting the kind of treatment I saw from some of you >>>>> reminds me of some of the black listing, and other nonsense that occurred >>>>> during the cold war. That is why we have a system that allows for >>>>> continual improvement. For those of you in the IT world and know about >>>>> ITIL think of the service life cycle and how something should be always >>>>> looked at during operation. Same thing applies here. Rules can be >>>>> improved, and just because you state them and blast them doesn't make >>>>> them right. >>> >>> Getting up on your soapbox, while cathartic, is mostly useless on a mailing >>> list. Comparing members of this list to McCarthyists and elementary >>> schoolers, is doubly counterproductive. Analogies are useful, but are not >>> particularly useful when dealing with specifics (like, say rules for the >>> FEISTFANS-L mailing list). >>> >>> If you want to effect change, *propose* something. If you think the >>> spoiler police is too heavy handed, volunteer to do it yourself for a while >>> and bring a gentler hand. If you don't like the spoiler rule, propose that >>> we suspend it for a while (one month, six months, etc.) and see if anyone >>> gets offended during that time. >>> >>> -Ray >>> >>
