(Intentionally top-posted)
Thank you, Paul. Thank you so much.
I used your command with some needed modifications: Copying existing DTS, coding to ac3,
'-disposition' to change the default soundtrack, and all the '-map'ping and codec '-copy'ing.
I've always thought that people learn more from success than from failure, and
you made it happen.
--Mark.
On 21/05/2024 16.04, Paul B Mahol wrote:
On Tue, May 21, 2024 at 10:52 AM Mark Filipak <markfilipak.i...@gmail.com>
wrote:
Attachments:
1. original ebur128.jpg
2. loudnorm-thresh=-85 pan ebur128.jpg
3. what I want ebur128.jpg
___1. The original
has a 'shelf' just below LU = -13. That's soft speech.
The peak is at LU = +9. That's shouting.
So the transform I want goes like this:
LU = -18..-14 gets no boost.
LU = -14..+9 gets a linear boost to -11..+9.
I assume 'LU' is Loudness Unit', eh? What is a loudness unit?
Now, the range of 'loudnorm=measured_thresh' is -99..0, so 100 steps.
Heaven knows what the scale is
and whether it's linear. No matter: Pressing on...
If LU = -18..9 maps linearly to 'measured_thresh' = -99..0, then Lu = -14
is 'measured_thresh' =
-85. I use "-85" in the next step.
___2. This command:
ffmpeg -i "original.mp4" -map 0:a -filter_complex
"[0:a]loudnorm=measured_thresh=-85,
pan=stereo|FL<FL+0.5*FC+0.6*BL+0.6*SL|FR<FR+0.5*FC+0.6*BR+0.6*SR,ebur128=video=1:peak=true[a]"
-map
"[a]" -c:v libx265 -x265-params crf=16 -c:a ac3 "loudnorm-thresh=-85 pan
ebur128.mp4"
maps LU = -13..+9 to -11..-7. That brings the soft speech up wonderfully,
but the shouting is dead.
___3. What I want maps LU = -14..+9 to -11..+9.
But to map linearly with 'loudnorm' I need to specify 4 parameters:
measured_I = -99..0
measured_LRA = 0..99
measured_TP = -99..99
measured_thresh = -99..0
I sorta know what 'thresh' is and I think it is '-85'. But I have no idea
what 'I' and 'LRA' and
'TP' are. I have no idea how to measure them. I have no idea what the
measurement units are. And I
have no idea what their physical meanings are.
Is there a way to measure the source video to determine these numbers? I'm
partway there, but the
rest of the way seems impossibly difficult; there's just too many unknowns.
Help! Please! I thank you,
ffmpeg -i input.video -af
"aformat=fltp,pan=stereo|FL=FL+FC+LFE+SL+BL|FR=FR+FC+LFE+SR+BR,alimiter"
-c:v copy output.video
Loudnorm filter in ffmpeg codebase is bad and ugly especially in dynamic
mode.
The best output is using limiter after just summing all channels, and not
scaling channels prior to summing at all.
This depends on quality of limiter filter, there are many alternative
limiters like with effects within ladspa, lv2 and clap (only in Librempeg).
_______________________________________________
ffmpeg-user mailing list
ffmpeg-user@ffmpeg.org
https://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-user
To unsubscribe, visit link above, or email
ffmpeg-user-requ...@ffmpeg.org with subject "unsubscribe".
