Oh no! Let's not start a long debate about whether it was On or Off topic! Can we not let this item rest in peace?
Don At 06:58 PM 23/06/2002 -0400, you wrote: >I have to say, I have been following this 'debate' from afar. Very afar, >because after the first few posts I, frankly, lost interest. However, I also >wholehearedly agree with Austin's post here. I do not see how anyone could >say that the discussion was off topic for a filmscanner list. Not my cup of >tea, but I certainly think it belongs on list for those that are interested. >If a topic is uninteresting to me, but still appropriate I just skim the post >or outright delete. Anyway, I will probably get flamed for this.... > >Howard > >Proper decorum and respect in discussion is another issue entirely and, >frankly, I haven't been following closely in that regard. Please don't >interpret my comment as suggesting that any type of decorum can be used >assuming that the subject is on topic. > > ><< > Hi Alex, > > It comes across that you (and some others) somehow believe the "Density vs > Dynamic Rage" thread was off-topic. In fact, it could not be more ON topic. > It may not be a topic that (unfortunately ) interests a lot of list members, > but it IS an important topic (far more important than a lot of people may > understand) that does relate to filmscanners. > > There are many topics on this, and other lists, that don't please > everyone...for one example, I could care less about Viewscan and Nikon > scanners (although some of the discussion about Nikon scanners does interest > me), but they ARE related to film scanners, and do belong here...except when > this group becomes a Viewscan support group...now that's out of line IMO. > > I believe this group is everything from "how do I turn my scanner on" to > "what is the spectral response of the LEDs in the Nikon 8000ED > scanner"...it's all about filmscanners. > > Regards, > > Austin > >> > >--------------------------------------------------------------------------- >------------- >Unsubscribe by mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED], with 'unsubscribe >filmscanners' >or 'unsubscribe filmscanners_digest' (as appropriate) in the message title >or body ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Unsubscribe by mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED], with 'unsubscribe filmscanners' or 'unsubscribe filmscanners_digest' (as appropriate) in the message title or body