At 06/03/2003 01:31 PM, Stu McIntire wrote:

>that comprise the music.  You can tweak a midi file to sound musical in the
>sense meant by this post, I am convinced.  Small adjustments to velocity,
>duration, and pitch as appropriate in a musical context can do the trick.  I
>sometimes wonder if metaphysical beliefs about the nature of music
>frequently blind teachers from developing practical suggestions that can
>help students improve in this area.

I took piano lessons ( long time ago) and was a hapless student.

One day she played my lesson and said (playing the piano) "This is the way that you play it."

And then she said (playing the piano) "This is the way it should be played."

And I, as a person with a Master's degree in music theory, said I could hear absolutely no difference.

Some things cannot be taught.

And it probably explains why my wife, who teaches 50 piano students a week, refused to give me lessons ;-)

Phil Daley          < AutoDesk >
http://www.conknet.com/~p_daley

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://mail.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to