On 07-01-18, at 23:30, Fiskum, Steve wrote:

Hello Éric,

Let me stray from the EPS subject a bit...

I was in your boat for a long time. We were going to keep PageMaker running as long as we could and stick with OS9 files and keep our files in versions 3.5.2 thru 2003 until we came to the conclusion that this was not a viable solution. Yes, it is a band-aid but if I were you, I would not count on MakeMusic prioritizing YOUR upgrade paths for your older files. There priority has never been the upgrading of files...it has always been adding new features with little regard to how files update.

For instance, if you open a 3.5.2 file in 2007 you will lose ALL text blocks. If you open the same file in 2006 those text blocks will be there. How long will it be before you will have to re- engrave all of your files because the structure of the program does not allow you to update these older files?

The finale files are not the problem, because once the eps are embedded into the pagemaker doc we do not need them anymore, except for occasional correction of mistakes.


You mentioned the EPS issues of letters with accents on them not printing out correctly. When I have mentioned issues like these to people at MakeMusic I have said, "It's great to have all of these new features but if I cannot output it correctly what good is the program?" They all seem to agree but nothing ever gets addressed. How in the world can a music notation company release a product that doesn't print EVERYTHING on the screen!!? I just don't understand how they can think this is OK and not fix it immediately?

I believe that the folks at MakeMusic simply cannot see the big picture anymore. The are in their things and don't see the most important. It may be a very important factor if the wind turns and that the consensus in the publishing world be that Sibelius is THE choice publishers want.


I really woke up in regards to the issue of postscript and Open Type when I started to see Adobe (who created postscript) try to snuff out the EPS format in there apps and will probably continue to do so. If you go on the Adobe forums you can see the many discussions on this subject. This really makes me wonder what Finale is going to do for those of us who create unique page sizes for many different files because they are going to be laid-out in a book or being customized for electronically distributed products. Currently I extract them out as EPS files and they are created into PDFs. I cannot image having to go into Page Setup and creating a large number of custom page sizes before going directly to PDF. This is an issue that needs to be on MakeMusic's radar for the future.

There is a real dilemma we all face with the inadequate focus of MakeMusic's development of their software. They do not focus enough on the CORE of the program...they focus too much on the FLUFF. Yes, maybe the FLUFF sells but you can only ride that wave for so long. Eventually your main user base of publishers will decide that they can no longer rely on Finale and have to jump ship to another problematic piece of software (but different) and cross their fingers that this one will listen to the publishers (just like what happened when Finale first came out and everyone was using SCORE). Once they jump ship, they will force their composers and arrangers to use this OTHER piece of software for submissions (which is currently happening in some circles). The only thing that seems to be saving Finale in this area is XML but it's hard to determine how long that will last since they have not rewritten the plug-in documentation since FIN2003 (I think) and that ETFs are no longer an option. When will Sib. stop allowing XML output?

This past year I upgraded thousands of octavo and hymnal files to FIN2006 with very little headache. I still had to send it through a proofing process but it was minimal. Using QuicKeys to do most of the work overnight I could come in the next day and all of the files would be ready for tweaking or printing. One of the keys to upgrading these files, which range from 3.5.2 to 2003, was to NEVER update layout. Once you do, you will have a lot of work ahead of you. If you are just upgrading files to keep them in a current OS, change some copyrights, or to just put them in an updated version of the software, then this situation works well.

From what I have read and heard, upgrading to InDesign will make a lot of formatting in the text be lost. Then if we have to redo the page layout of all books containing text, proofing them to be sure that no typos or formating errors are stills there, then the cost for upgrading is simply too high. We are a small publisher with a big catalogue, and I don't believe we could afford to have one person working full-time for more than a year to make the transition. We'll have to move on some day somehow, but right now the perspectives are bad, and the reality is that we'll stay with pagemaker as long as we can get a G4 to run it.

It is strange because I love technology and progress, and do 90% of my work in OS X. But I am furious of the way Adobe simply has let the PageMaker community down. I guess that for some people it wasn't that hard to make the move. For us it is not a technical limitation that is holding the decision to move on. It is the huge costs involved in it.


Éric I understand your comment about it not being possible to switch to Open Type because it would break thousands of older files not to mention your PageMaker issues. I thought the same thing until I went through this exact same process this past year. It was not fun at first but you eventually figure out a work-flow and it is not as bad as you may think. PageMaker is dead! Adobe no longer develops the software. They have made it pretty easy to move PageMaker documents into InDesign and have added features like the Story Editor into InDesign to help make PageMaker switchers comfortable. Most of the devoted PageMaker designers I work with have been forced to switch to InDesign (reluctantly) and have said to me after this past year, that they would never want to go back. They love InDesign. Once you block out the time and do the prep correctly, the process can go pretty smoothly.

Getting back to Finale...I'm pretty unhappy the way MakeMusic has dealt with the publishers and the professional engravers over the years. I keep hearing that they are now listening to these two groups but to me it is not showing.

I also get the impression that they take it seriously when I submit bugs, but like you I don't see the results.

Again, the main problem for me is not OS X, it is that eps are broken and they don't have enough will to repair it. I would help as much as I could to make things progress, and I did spend an awful lot of time tracking the cause of my eps problems with techsupport, but so far no results. Is it that hard to make my music print as it looks on- screen? It is just this that I want (well...almost...).

Thanks anyway Steve for your thoughts.

(btw, following a further response to that thread, would it work if I could find an old enough version of Times, Helvetica, New Century Schoolbook, Modern fonts to export my eps?)
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to