I can second Mark's comment about publishers reluctant to publish an
arrangement of a song they already have more than one of in their
catalog. Years ago I was asked to do an arrangement of "Amazing
Grace" for a local choir that was going to Russia on an exchange
program. The Russians loved it, and everyone I talk to says it's the
best arrangement they have heard - better than any of the published
ones. Still, although my editor friend at my publisher really likes
it, he said they couldn't publish it because there were at least
three other arrangements of it in their catalog. I'm sure that's true
of other publishers I've worked with. At least the tune and the words
are in the public domain, and anyone interested in performing my
arrangement can pay me for copies. I've had lots of performances of
it this way.
Hal Owen
With alll the usual I-am-not-a-lawyer caveats:
In my experience, your best chance to get permission to publish an
arrangement of a copyrighted work is if the copyright belongs to an
individual, non-commercial composer. If that's the case, you have
to track down him or her, but once you do you can discuss ideas
person to person. Maybe the composer still says no, but at least
you had a rational negotiation about it.
If the copyright belongs to a publishing house, as it does for
nearly all the good songs, then unless you're planning to arrange
for some combination of instruments they haven't done yet and for
which there might be some commercial demand, then you're almost
certainly out of luck. The answer will be, "We already have an SATB
arrangement of song X, so we don't need another one. Here is the
catalog number in case you wish to purchase it." Nevermind that
you've already seen that arrangement and everyone in the business
thinks it's dogcrap and that's exactly why you want to publish a
better one. The publisher doesn't see it that way. All they see is
they've already got that item in the catalog so they have no motive
to allow another one.
As David Bailey suggested, you can still perform your arrangement.
Assuming you have the usual permissions to perform the piece, there
is no expectation that you're going to perform every note exactly as
written. You may of course add your own creativity to your
performance of the piece ... and if that creativity entails some
rearrangement, it's not unreasonable that you'd need to write that
down for your performers. But this writing down must be for your
performers' use only, and you'd better not let copies propagate
enough that it looks like you're publishing. You probably should
refrain from writing "arranged by" on the music or in the program
because, strictly speaking, arranging is exactly what the
publisher's copyright forbids you to do. You're just helping to
coordinate the performers' interpretation of the piece.
mdl
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
--
Harold Owen
1375 Olive Street #402, Eugene, OR 97401
mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Visit my web site at:
http://uoregon.edu/~hjowen/
FAX: (509) 461-3608
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale