First off, Finale may not be authorizing those sales and they may be pirated copies.

Secondly, even if they are not pirated copies, they may be copies purchased from a music retailer who has gone bankrupt. In such cases all assets are sold off at auction and somebody may have paid ten-cents on the dollar to buy that stock, which is why they can offer them for sale so cheaply and still make a profit.

These days I'm the last person to leap to MakeMusic's defense, but in this case until you know for certain that the company OEM Software Resellers purchased those copies directly from MakeMusic and didn't buy them through a liquidation sale, it's a bit premature to get irate over the low price.

Secondly, it's important that we all remember that MakeMusic has never forced anybody to upgrade. At least as far as I know, they've never put a gun to anybody's head and said "Buy this upgrade for $100 or I'll blow your head off." They have forced people who deal with others (who have bought the upgrade) to buy the upgrade in order to be version compatible to share files, but that is a very small percentage of the Finale-user-base. If you have fallen for the "upgrade this year to get even better, more unbelievably gorgeous output with even less effort" trap (as I have for practically every upgrade) it's not the company's fault -- it's your fault for buying their "you really need this upgrade" crap.

Yes, you have spent $2400 approximately to get to where you are as a Finale user -- had you not spent that money, you'd be theoretically much richer but you wouldn't have had the advantage of all these years of Finale use. A new user will always arrive at the same level of program features spending far less than a person who has used the program for many years and upgraded each year. It's a fact of software life, not specifically related to Finale but to all software programs.

Even if a new user paid the full $699 dollars they'd still be spending far less than you've spent over the years.

You may be right in thinking that Finale2010 can do all you'd ever want a notation program to do, and in that case there is no need to buy Finale2011. I skipped Finale2009 but fell for the Finale2010 upgrade and am sorry I did so. It offers me nothing by way of improvement for my notational needs over Finale2008. But I fell for it and have nobody but myself to blame for it.

So skip the next few upgrades and don't buy another upgrade until you find one that really offers significant improvement over the version you currently have. I know that's what I'll be doing.

David H. Bailey



Michael Greensill wrote:
I just got an e-mail from some company called OEM software resellers, who are offering the full Finale 2010 for $119. A savings of $480 off the retail price.

Is anyone else as pissed off as me that having owned Finale since 3.0 in 1992 and being forced to pay approximately $100 every year to upgrade...Finale must have cost me around $2400.

They should at least give long time owners a free upgrade now and then just for loyalty.

I'm pretty happy with 2010, so I think I'm done with upgrading. What else can they offer me? Unless they come up with some method of actually doing my work for me!

Mike G.

www.mikegreensill.com

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale



--
David H. Bailey
[email protected]
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to