On 4 Oct 2009 at 8:17, Aaron Sherber wrote:

> On 10/3/2009 10:08 PM, David W. Fenton wrote:
> > On the other hand, for those of us who do our engraving gratis,
> > there's no amount of hours saved multiplied by an hourly rate of $0
> > that will offset the upgrade price.
> 
> Actually, you're looking at this backwards. For those who charge an 
> hourly rate for engraving, there's a kind of incentive to stay with 
> older versions, to bill more hours on a project and make more money. On 
> the other hand, every hour that someone like you spends in Finale is an 
> hour that you could have spent doing something else that you do get paid 
> for, so you have an incentive to upgrade and minimize your non-billable 
> hours.

No one who wants to stay in business for long will artificially 
inflate hours -- they will lose customers by doing so, and if they 
have a conscience, they will be feel bad about doing so.

As to my own personal time management, this week was an unusual case, 
but entirely my own fault -- I was supposed to have done the 
engraving work on the weekend, but was too fascinated by my Pachelbel 
investigations and didn't get around to.

In short, my Finale work is weekend work, a hobby, if you will (even 
though I would say my engraving stacks up with that of many who get 
paid for it). 

Secondly, as I said in my original post, there's nothing I can think 
of in recent versions of Finale that would have made the process 
faster than it already ways. After many years of struggling with 
extracting parts, I finally figured out the proper settings to get 
parts that need tweaking only in fitting to the appropriate number of 
pages -- e.g., a part that comes out with 2 pages and 3 systems needs 
to be revised to fit on two pages, while a part that comes to 1 and a 
half pages needs to be adjusted to spread out over the two pages. 
Neither of these are things that later versions of Finale can do 
automatically, so I'd still have to do it all myself. 

In the particular music I was working on Wednesday, very little time 
would have been saved by even automatic layout, because I was 
preparing a part that was only a partial part, i.e., p. 3 of the full 
part, and I didn't care that much about how the whole part was laid 
out -- I forced the final movement onto the last page and tweaked the 
top margin and was ready to go. Had I been producing a full part, 
there would have been much more work.

But this is about my own time management, and a new version of Finale 
would not have saved me enough time on this particular project to 
have contributed significantly to financing an upgrade. Not all such 
projects would be so little effected by the new features, but the 
more a project is streamlined by those features, the more likely it's 
a big enough project that I wouldn't be working on it during my 
"business hours."

> > And that's why we don't buy it like a subscription. Changing the
> > terminology won't change my Finale purchase pattern on iota.
> > Would it change yours? I doubt it.
> 
> Either I'm being really unclear, or you're really misreading what I've 
> been repeatedly saying. No, it wouldn't change my purchase pattern. But 
> it would change the way I feel about it. Right now, I resent Makemusic 
> for essentially having a subscription but not saying so, for giving the 
> impression that the software I buy provides benefits for longer than a 
> year, as every other piece of software I buy does. If they were more 
> upfront about only providing upgrades for a year and so forth, I 
> wouldn't be resentful. YMMV.

But you know that's what they do, so it seems irrational to me to 
assert that it's their fault that you feel that way.

My worry is that if they switched their terminology to call it a 
subscription, they'd feel less pressure to make the yearly update 
significant.

-- 
David W. Fenton                    http://dfenton.com
David Fenton Associates       http://dfenton.com/DFA/

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to