I don't mean to be acting as an apologist for MakeMusic, but I just 
don't think that people are asking reasonable questions here.

On 21 Oct 2009 at 14:44, Eric Dannewitz wrote:

> Speaking of TGTools, it is rather shocking that MakeMusic would not  work
> with Tobias to ensure that his plugin works properly with Finale.

And what makes you think they haven't? My guess is that Tobias is a 
beta tester so he knows what's going on. I'd also guess that as one 
of the most important plugin developers he has no trouble getting 
through to the programming team to discuss issues.

If the problems haven't been fixed, that tells me:

1. the problems are quite difficult, OR

2. Tobias has not given it full attention yet.

3. both (#2 could be triggered by #1, for instance)

I'm not saying any of these alternatives are the case, but I don't 
see that it's proper to blame MM for Tobias's lack of an updated 
release.

>  It took
> months for an update to work with the new dynamics (as I  recall) and
> people are still waiting for an update to get the Chords  working properly
> again.

I don't see what the justification is for blaming MM for this. Even 
if Tobias only got the new version at the same time everyone else 
did, at that point, it's all on him to revise his plugin to work with 
the new version. Clearly, MM can help him to make the process as 
smooth as possible, but at a certain point, updating the plugin is 
the responsibility of the plugin developer, not of MM.

Obviously, in order to maintain an active stable of plugin developers 
MM has to pay attention to them and try not to introduce changes into 
Finale that break existing plugins any more than is necessary. But 
have we heard from any plugin developers that MM has been doing this? 
Perhaps we wouldn't, as they can't badmouth MM without possibly 
endangering their insider access.

> I for one wish MakeMusic would put in a "save to previous version"  
> feature to at least make sure people with in the last version (2009)  can
> read files created with the new version. Sibelius seems to offer  this.

I am sure that if implementing this were easy without major and 
extensive changes to the codebase, MM would implement it. Sibelius 
has one major advantage over MM and that is that their codebase is 
about a decade younger than MM's and probably has a lot less cruft in 
it to handle legacy issues. As a non-programmer, you might be 
surprised at how much a difference that can make.

-- 
David W. Fenton                    http://dfenton.com
David Fenton Associates       http://dfenton.com/DFA/

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to