On 31 Oct 2009 at 6:34, dhbailey wrote:

> Eric Dannewitz wrote:
> > Loading up a full orchestra or wind band score with full garritan sounds?
> 
> Is that Sibelius's fault or GPO's fault?

Or the Aria player (or whichever player your version of Finale uses 
for GPO sounds)?

And that raises the question of whether or not a 4GB-aware Sibelius 
launching its GPO player somehow makes the GPO player 4GB-aware, too. 
That's something I strongly doubt.

On the other hand, if Sibelius (or Finale) can launch those child 
processes in their own memory spaces (even if, for instance, they are 
only 2GB-aware), the more memory space Sib/Fin has to load them in, 
the better.

And on the other hand (you didn't know I had three hands, heh? Well, 
I have only two nipples...), that may be something that's handled by 
the OS, though the /LARGEADDRESSAWARE is something that causes the OS 
to treat memory requests differently. That is, if the app is known to 
the OS to be able to handle the larger address space, the OS will 
utilize it in the application's behalf. 

>  For those of us 
> who use soundfonts or external midi devices for playback, 
> there's no need for such huge amounts of RAM.  For people 
> who insist on using softsynths, there will always be a need 
> for huge amounts of RAM until the softsynth people come up 
> with new algorithms.  But that's hardly the fault of the 
> notation software companies, MakeMusic or Sibelius.

And, of course, all of this is completely ludicrous in comparison to 
the situation with OS X Snow Leopard, which is 64-bit. Wrangling over 
the benefits of an OS that can make a full 4GBs available to apps vs. 
making, say, 3.5GBs available seems really crazy when Snow Leopard 
supports 16TBs of RAM (that's 16,000GBs). Certainly, 64-bit Windows 
also supports large amounts of RAM, but the apps have to be compiled 
appropriately (you can't just run a 32-bit app on 64-bit Windows and 
expect it to see and use your 8GBs of RAM). But multiple apps can 
certainly be given lots more memory space individually, and for 
Garritan, that could be significant. That is, the OS could give 
Sibelius/Finale 4GBs and then give your GPO player 4GBs. Each app 
couldn't see more than its 32-bit limitations allow, but the OS could 
marshall them in a way that would give a lot more headroom than on a 
32-bit OS (where the OS and all apps are limited to sharing the max 
of 4GBs).

-- 
David W. Fenton                    http://dfenton.com
David Fenton Associates       http://dfenton.com/DFA/

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to