On 1 Nov 2009 at 8:19, Johannes Gebauer wrote: > I specifically said that while the main release cycle is slower they > usually have several maintenance releases. 6.1 is a maintenance. They > are _quicker_ with maintenances than Finale ever tried to be. > > They are quicker if you take all releases, and this was a small number, > and cost nothing.
Well, I don't think you're correct. Sibelius releases a never version pretty much every 2 years (according to the Wikipedia article). But how many maintenance releases are there between major releases? This article: http://www.sibeliusblog.com/opinion/the-story-behind-sibelius-6-part- 1/ ...says there were 3 for Sibelius 5. But how is that any different from Finale? There are usually 1-2 maintenance releases of Finale between yearly versions, also (2009 had 2 updates, for instance). So if Sibelius 5's maintenance release schedule is any indication, that means that they are pretty much at parity in the number of maintenance releases over the same time period. But the article about Sibelius cited above indicates that Sibelius 5 was unusual in having been released with more issues than normal and thus they created more maintenance releases then normal -- at least, that's how I read this paragraph: The result of all this [a description of all the major behind-the-scenes changes implemented in Sib5], coupled with a certain amount of user apprehension about what it would mean for their favourite little notation company to have been acquired by a big corporation like Avid, was that we put our users through a certain amount of pain in the early days following Sibelius 5´s release, and that experience has really stuck with us. We worked hard to make improvements to reduce those pain points, and while we were also working on the localised versions of Sibelius 5 (which were finally finished a year after the English release of Sibelius 5.0), we were able to issue three maintenance releases that got Sibelius 5 to the point where we are all as proud of it as we wanted to be from the outset. This doesn't sound like a description of their usual practice. But even if it is, it's just at parity with Finale in terms of *number* of maintenance releases. Now, if you want to argue about the significance of the updates, have at it. I have no knowledge one way or the other, having used neither Sibelius nor recent versions of Finale. But it's not on point to what I said, i.e., that because of the slower release schedule, Sibelius needed to get Win7 4GB memory support into a maintenance release, whereas MM could easily queue up that feature for their next full release without it being an issue. I will give Sibelius credit for introducing the support in the same month that the new OS version shipped. There's nothing magical about that, since everybody who wants it has had access to the Win7 betas in nearly complete form for almost a year, but it shows good planning such that they timed it well. But I still don't think it's some kind of major feature, as Henry cast it in his cryptic post (we still don't even know for certain if that was what he was referring to). -- David W. Fenton http://dfenton.com David Fenton Associates http://dfenton.com/DFA/ _______________________________________________ Finale mailing list [email protected] http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
