On 20 Nov 2009 at 9:03, dhbailey wrote:

> It's like music with triplets, from the Baroque era and shortly
> thereafter, where one part has triplet 8ths and the other part has
> dotted-8ths and 16ths, yet the music is engraved so that the dotted
> 8th lines up with the first of the triplet, and the 16th lines up with
> the last triplet, indicating  that rather than a 3:1 ratio as we would
> normally interpret dotted-8th/16th rhythms, the dotted-8th/16th should
> be interpreted with a 2:1 ratio, as if they were triplets.  Just
> easier and more clear (in their minds) than putting a quarter and an
> 8th together with a triplet bracket. 

I'd like to hear about some of these specific examples of engraving 
where the rhythms are lined up like that. None of the engraving from 
the period before c. 1820 or so that I've encountered is that careful 
with vertical alignment one way or the other. First off, almost none 
of the music is in score, so only keyboard parts would have any 
chance of showing this, and they didn't make much effort at vertical 
alignment in the keyboard parts I've seen.

Your point is still correct in regard to how they notated triplet 
rhythms, but I don't think vertical alignment in contemporary sources 
is good evidence for it.

-- 
David W. Fenton                    http://dfenton.com
David Fenton Associates       http://dfenton.com/DFA/

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to