David W. Fenton wrote:

>> I find that nowadays I am bothered less by failure to avoid  
>> collisions than errors of overzealous collision avoidance, especially
>> with slurs. Finale's mechanisms mostly succeed in avoiding collisions 
>> but only at the cost of frequently lifting slurs further than they 
>> really need to be lifted, with the result that the music, although 
>> lacking any egregious error that requires fixing, is just less 
>> attractive overall.
>
>Isn't this something that Finale 2010 was supposed to have addressed 
>finally?

I'm not talking about the crazy wacko slurs where it jumps really high to avoid 
an accidental. Yes, those have been fixed. I'm talking about the many slurs 
where it looks OK but it could be better. But I know I'm pickier than most.

Finale is working with basic algorithms and can't bring the same intelligence 
as a live engraver can to determining what would be most aesthetically pleasing 
for a slur in a given situation. It doesn't even do that great a job with slurs 
even when collisions aren't involved. We've just learned to accept them because 
that's what the software does and it seems normal to us now.

mdl
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to