On 24 Jun 2010 at 0:11, John Howell wrote:

> At 3:19 PM -0400 6/23/10, David W. Fenton wrote:
> >
> >But the whole point is that any income is just gravy. That's not at
> >all the point of the project. That doesn't mean I don't want to
> >maximize it, just that it's not the most important consideration.
> 
> Not quite, as was pointed out by my daughter, the math teacher.  Any
> PROFIT, defined as income minus expenses, is gravy.  Big difference.
> And all the expenses are up front.

When you don't care about profit, and are happy to even just give 
away all the CDs produced, profit is simply not relevant. Sure, any 
income from CD sales would go to support the group's activities, but 
there's no way it could earn back what it costs to produce the album.

And even if we somehow earned enough to pay for the pressing of the 
CDs and the organ rental (500 CDs sold at $10 each would barely earn 
it back, once out-of-pocket production costs are paid), that doesn't 
begin to compensate for all the work put into the project by people 
who are not being paid $$$ for their work.

Profit is not a concept we care about. We look at all expenses as 
sunk costs, never to be recovered.

> My university show ensemble used to make an album yearly, strictly for
> souvenir sales, and my goal was to earn back enough to fund the next
> year's album production.  We did.  And interestingly enough,
> Diskmakers was the outfit we used, although my last experience with
> them was almost 20 year ago.

I would think everything is different about them now.

> They can do any artwork you want, at a price.  We always sent 
> everything to them camera ready, laid out properly my my Public 
> Relations Staff.  What they have is a variety of standard art for the
> covers, and as long as you're happy with one of them, you're fine. Any
> changes will cost you.

There's no question that we will be providing our own camera-ready 
artwork. The big question is how many pages we can afford in the 
booklet. To fit in text and translations and notes, we'd surely need 
an 8-page booklet, but that would likely cost substantially more than 
pressing the physical CDs themselves. So, we're likely to go with a 
cheap insert and provide specially prepared materials for sending 
with promotional CDs, and keeping the rest on our website (or, 
perhaps, putting a data partition on the CD; perhaps).

At the point we are ready to firm up the numbers, I'll request 
quotes. I have no idea if we can fit a cover image, the program on 
the back of the jewel case, and then the notes and text/translations 
into the remaining seven pages of CD-sized (and that's assuming no 
repetition of the track listing). Probably we'd have to do it in six 
in order to have room for credits.

It's probably simply not doable, and anything above that is probably 
way more expensive than we'd want to go, unless we can come up with a 
printer who can do better (which I doubt).

-- 
David W. Fenton                    http://dfenton.com
David Fenton Associates       http://dfenton.com/DFA/

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to