I'm going to jump in with my 2 cents worth.  As usual (maybe always:), 
Christopher has it right.  What Craig describes as looking amateurish and 
cluttered is built into Finale's way of handling expressions on MM rests.  As 
Christopher points out, Finale only knows how to show an expression as attached 
to the first measure of a MM rest, if an expression in the score is attached to 
the last measure of a MM rest, it will appear in the part only if that last 
measure is broken off (widowed) as Craig describes.  This annoying limitation 
has been built in as long as I can remember, and my workaround is to add 
duplicate expressions to the parts that are set not to show in the score.  This 
is clumsy and time consuming but results in the parts looking better.  Using 
this method, a DS al Coda can appear in a part at the end of an 8 measure rest 
instead of having a 7 measure rest and a separated single measure showing the 
expression.  I have tried to think if a simple mechanism Finale programmers 
could use to circumvent this limitation so that I could recommend it to them, 
but I have yet to come up with one.

As long as the parts are not more than 3 pages long, it is easier for the 
player to continue reading forward, so I tend towards mass copying material to 
avoid DSs and Jump to Coda signs, but sometimes they are necessary.  They can 
be made to work using "hide in score - show in part" methods, but this is a 
part of Finale's construction that runs counter to what I think of as normal 
and straightforward.

Chuck


On Jan 31, 2014, at 11:34 AM, Craig Parmerlee <[email protected]> wrote:

> Let me see if I can explain more clearly.  I have an 8-bar section -- 
> bars 50-57 -- where most of the winds are resting.  The "To coda" jump 
> occurs at the end of bar 56.  That is where I placed the mark in the 
> score.  In the parts that are resting, I expect to see a SEVEN BAR mm 
> rest (50-56) that has a "to coda" at the rightmost end of that mm rest, 
> followed by a loner measure rest for measure 57.  I absolutely do NOT 
> want measure 56 to be split off on its own.  That looks amateurish to me 
> and is unnecessarily cluttered.
> 
> When in the score, I selected everything and created MM rests for all 
> parts.  Finale got that bit exactly right, IMHO.  For the parts that are 
> resting, I have a 7-bar mm rest (50-56) plus bar 57 which must be on its 
> own because it is after the coda jump. That's perfect.
> 
> What ain't so good is that Finale put the "To Coda" mark in a crappy 
> place.  It must go at the rightmost end of that mm rest for the musician 
> to immediately know exactly where the coda jump occurs.  And they 
> compounded the problem by making it impossible to move the "To coda" 
> mark as long as it is within the mm rest.  I can coax the mark into an 
> acceptable location by breaking the mm rest while editing the linked 
> part, moving the mark slightly, and then recreating the mm rest within 
> that linked part.  That's a little tedious but it works.
> 
> 
> On 1/31/2014 12:30 PM, Williams, Jim wrote:
>> Am I missing something here? A to coda instruction should break a mm rest, 
>> even if it's the last measure of an mm rest. Maybe that's not the Finale 
>> default, but I would break an mm rest for anything like a fermata, to coda, 
>> etc.  I wrong to do that?
>> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Finale mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
> 

Chuck Israels
8831 SE 12th Ave.
Portland, OR 97202-7097

land line: (503) 954-2107
cell phone: (360) 201-3434

<www.chuckisraelsjazz.com>

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to