There are several examples on this page:

http://www.noteperformer.com/?mode=

It seems they used crappy samples for Finale, and they also have the 
volume about 4 db lower.  The loudness of the Sibelius samples makes the 
product sound "better" but that is basically a cheap parlor trick.

There may be some additional benefits from NotePerformer, but mostly 
what I hear is a whole lot of reverb.  I don't nee to pay $129 just to 
get more reverb.  If there are other benefits from NotePerformer, they 
are hard to hear because of the excessive reverb.  This seems pretty 
sleazy to me.



On 2/18/2014 6:59 AM, David H. Bailey wrote:
> On 2/17/2014 9:40 PM, Ryan wrote:
>> Anyone know anything about this?
>> http://www.noteperformer.com/?ref=fb
>
> All I know about it is that there have been some discussion about it on
> the Sibelius list and that it seems like it takes some work to get great
> results and it's best for classical (i.e. non-jazz, non-show, non-rock,
> etc.) music right now and not so great for other styles.
>
> I believe that you can submit a file to the makers and they will send
> back an audio file of what they were able to do with your Sibelius file,
> as a teaser to get people to buy the product.  I'm always leery of such
> offers because I've been duped in the past by demos of products where
> the demo sounds fantastic and I've bought a product only to realize that
> the demo was obviously worked on by a person who was able to spend the
> entire work day preparing the demos, over who-knows-how-many weeks, and
> they were completely versed in the inner workings of the product.  My
> results on the same product, where I have limited time to spend getting
> one file perfect since I have to support myself by doing work others
> will pay me for, were much less satisfying.
>
> So even if the makers of NotePerformer were able to send me an audio
> file that would blow me away, there's no way of knowing (without buying
> the product) if I would be able to come close to the same results.
>
> There has not been a groundswell of people buying that product and then
> raving about it on the Sibelius list at yahoogroups.
>
>


_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to