The problem in this case is that there is some obsolete material in your documentation. It has since been updated on the Fink website. If I remember correctly, originally there were two XFree86 packages for Fink:

1) xfree86-base, which contained most of the guts of X, including the libraries and header files

2) xfree86-server, which contained the display server. Included in this package is XDarwin, the Mac application that starts X in parallel with the Aqua environment (hence the reason that the two get mentioned in the same context). This package provided only a fullscreen X display on a separate virtual window.

Meanwhile, the rootless display option was being developed, which led to the "roaming rootless servers" mentioned in the docs, and the Fink package:

3) xfree86-rootless. This was essentially the same as 2), but also had the option to
display in rootless mode. This was initially regarded as experimental, but after much evaluation, it was regarded as stable.

One could install 1) and 2) or 1) and 3) .

Once the rootless option became the norm, the xfree86-server package went away, all of its functionality subsumed into xfree8-rootless.

For XFree86-4.3.0, it was decided to simplify things yet further, and just have the xfree86 package, which contains everything (well, there are xfree86 and xfree86-shlibs packages, but you can't have the first without the second).

I hope this clarifies things (I spent a fair amount of time working on revising the chapter you cited!)

On Wednesday, July 2, 2003, at 11:46 PM, Brian Egeness wrote:

<snip>
You misunderstood when I spoke of a lack of top-down logic flowchart-like documentation. Fink is a breeze to install, which I mentioned, and the documentation for it...perfect! Kudos to the author! I probably shouldn't have posted here but the fink community seemed very helpful as well. Salute~ Anyway, it was the lack of docs with a list of specific packages to complete one basic working xfree86 client-server system on a 10.2.6 box that I was talking about. Ideally, I was hoping to find a beginner's bundle package governed by user OS and work environment preference. But lack of docs compounded by the fact that an Xserver, essential to the build, is nowhere to be found for download confused me and opened up version compatibility questions and more questions until my brain hurt. Have a look-see:

User's Guide - 3 Installing Packages
....

3.1 Getting X11 Sorted Out
....

xfree86-base: This package is the real thing. It installs the whole load of XFree86 as a Fink package. For maximum flexibility, this package does not contain the actual XDarwin server. To get that, you can install the xfree86-server or the xfree86-rootless package. Or you can install it manually, for example using an "XDarwin" test release from the XonX project or one of the "rootless" servers circulating the net.

This is what put the wrench in it for me. Trying to figure out...XDarwin? or xfree86-server? Hmmm...what's the right choice here. Maybe I should go rootless after all? Am I going to d/l one of these to find that it has issues under Darwin 6.6 arch.? This paragraph implied to me that the xfree86-server IS available by calling "fink install xfree86-server". But it's not available from the command line "install" call or by a query to "fink list" or manual d/l for that matter. At least give a direct link or 2 to a d/l that works. If it's at the cvs repository then that's another can of worms for me specifically that I don't wanna get into. Suffice to say, incompatible scripting with my isp's framework i think...Virgin Island sys admins...oowee!. But after reading the docs, it mentions that it is desirable to use "fink install" for or compatibility issues may arise. Let's face it. Some parts of the documentation lack target value for the new user. The User's Guide even calls the same Xserver by 2 different names (XDarwin and xfree86-server) in one paragraph. That's confusing for the new user who doesn't know the difference? Granted, no one gets paid to do this but if I advertise Fish...I'm gonna call it Fish and I'm gonna give em Fish! hehe...
<snip>
Alexander K. Hansen
Levitated Dipole Experiment
http://www.psfc.mit.edu/LDX

Reply via email to