Religion: the resurrection
Not long ago, organised faith seemed to be on its last legs. Now it is again a 
force to be reckoned with
 


Andrew Brown 
The Guardian, 
Tuesday October 28 2008 
 
The return of ideology has taken us all by surprise, because no one expected it 
all to be about religion. Twenty years ago, when the Berlin Wall fell and it 
seemed reasonable to suppose that all the big questions about how to organise 
society had been solved by history, if you had asked what could possibly 
disrupt this progressive consensus, hardly anyone would have supposed that the 
answer had anything to do with God. 

 
There may have been a few prescient pessimists who thought Islam would be an 
important and dangerous disruption on the forward march to the future - perhaps 
important and dangerous enough to need quelling with a few brisk, punitive 
expeditions - but even such pessimists could hardly have imagined the fiasco 
that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have turned out to be, nor 9/11 attacks 
and the widespread fear and loathing they have produced. 
Nor could anyone have foreseen the emergence of the religious right as such a 
dominant force in American politics and its extraordinary takeover of the 
Republican party. 
 
But now the Reaganite model of capitalism is collapsing around us, liberal 
democracy is no longer poised to take over the world but worrying about where 
and how it may survive - and the arguments about religion are back as fiercely 
as ever, and almost as popular. This is extraordinary. Communism would not have 
fallen in the way it did were it not for the passionate Roman Catholicism of 
the Poles, and even in the other countries of eastern 
Europe there were Christian groupings at the forefront of the revolutions of 
1989: Lutherans in Germany, Calvinists in Romania. But these atavistic 
throwbacks, while they might have outlasted communism, seemed helpless against 
capitalism. 
 
Sure enough, the Catholic church in Ireland imploded in scandals, and even in 
Poland lost much of its influence. The slow etiolation of liberal Protestantism 
continued. The simple message of hedonistic liberalism - there is probably no 
God; there is nothing to worry about; enjoy yourselves - seemed in the west 
entirely self-evident. The wierdos who didn't know the enjoyment of this life 
was all one could hope for were clearly dying off and religion was no more than 
a "licensed insanity", in the words of John Bowker, then dean of Trinity. 
 
What changed? What brought us to the contemporary world, where millions of 
Muslims, Christians, atheists and Hindus understand the existence of infidels 
and heretics as an existential threat, against which almost any degree of 
violence is sometimes justified? The one thing that almost all intellectuals 
would now agree on is that other people's theological and philosophical 
opinions threaten the continuation of human life, a belief unknown since the 
cold war. Of course, we all disagree about which beliefs are dangerous. Nor is 
there any accepted way to resolve these disagreements, or even to live with 
them. 
 
Part of the answer to what changed is obviously Islam. Without the attacks of 
September 11, and before them the fatwa on Salman Rushdie, the idea that 
religion might be dangerous as well as wrong would not be nearly so widespread. 
But it is also, I think, related to a general realisation that, for whatever 
reason, the welfare states of western Europe have fallen far short of their 
original promise. Whether you blame Thatcherism or the 60s, it no longer seems 
self-evident that everyone will continue to get richer, less violent and better 
educated in the way that everyone took for granted in the years when churches 
were collapsing.
 
Marx said: "Religious distress is at the same time the expression of real 
distress and the protest against real distress. Religion is the sigh of the 
oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, just as it is the spirit of 
a spiritless situation. It is the opium of the people... The demand to give up 
the illusion about its condition is the demand to give up a condition that 
needs illusions." 
 
I agree, but what if we cannot give up the "condition that needs illusions"? 
What if the demand to give it up is itself as infantile a piece of 
wish-fulfilment as anything in anyone's scriptures? The fear of these questions 
is surely part of the explanation for the hysterical and apocalyptic tone of 
some atheists. 
 
Asking these questions doesn't guarantee an answer, but they suddenly seem 
pressing, which guarantees that religion will continue its resurrection. That's 
one reason for the paper's new site, Comment is free: Belief, today. 
 
Andrew Brown is author of The Darwin Wars and editor of the Guardian's new 
faith site at guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/belief 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2008/oct/28/religion-islam-christianity-reaganism


      
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
Ju merrni këtë mesazh sepse jeni të anëtarësuar në grupin "Fjala e Bukur" në 
Google Groups.
Për të dërguar në këtë grup, dërgo email në [email protected]
Për t'u ç'anëtarësuar nga ky grup, dërgo email në [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Për më shumë mundësi, vizito këtë grup në 
http://groups.google.com/group/fjalaebukur
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Antwoord per e-mail aan