Islamophobia worse than racial prejudice 

The secretary-general of the Organization of the Islamic Conference (OIC), 
Eklemeddin İhsanoğlu, has told a Danish newspaper that Western institutions 
which deal with Islamophobia agree that hatred against Islam and Muslims is 
worse than racial discrimination. 


 
"Incitement to religious hatred is a new form of racism, and Western 
institutions dealing with Islamophobia are unanimous in saying that the 
phenomenon of Islamophobia is worse than racial discrimination," he stated in a 
recent written interview with the Danish Jyllands-Posten daily. 
 
İhsanoğlu stressed that discrimination is discrimination whether on religious 
or racial grounds. İhsanoğlu also clearly expressed that the OIC is neither 
against criticism of religion nor is it calling for a ban on any criticism of 
religion.
 
The full text of the written interview with the questions of Jyllands-Posten, a 
copy of which was also sent to Today's Zaman, is as follows: 
Can you explain why you believe that criticism of religion can be defined as 
racism?
First of all, let me be very clear on one point. We are neither against 
criticism of religion nor do we call for a ban on criticizing religion. The 
history of religions, including Islam, is a history of criticism and debate 
which has led to the formation of different sects and schools of thought. These 
debates have always been there at the academic, scholarly or theological level. 
As for debates which are conducted at the level of public opinion, we have no 
problem with any criticism, as long as they are objective, fair and conducted 
in a responsible manner.
 
The problems start when the religious beliefs of individuals belonging to any 
religion or venerated religious figures, i.e., prophets, whether Muhammad, 
Jesus or Moses, are ridiculed, denigrated or targeted with campaigns of insults 
with apparent or declared intent to incite hatred against the followers of this 
or that religion. I am quite surprised to see in the Danish press insinuations 
that I and the OIC are opponents of freedom of expression, endeavoring to 
stifle this freedom by calling for a ban on the criticism of religion. 
 
Everybody is entitled to criticize anybody or anything. How it is done is 
completely up to one's own norms, values and style of expressing his or her 
ideas. We have no problem whatsoever with this. However, when the freedom of 
expression is abused to ridicule and demonize, with the intention of sowing 
seeds of hatred against a group of people or citizens, then problems begin 
because the rights of the victims of these incitements come to the fore. It is 
not only the OIC and I who express this belief. I believe that many Western 
dignitaries, including the UN secretary-general and the UN high representative 
for the Alliance of Civilizations have expressed the same opinion. Moreover, 
the international community has given its frank endorsement to this opinion, 
through resolutions adopted by the UN General 
Assembly and the UN Human Rights Council, passed with large majorities. Thus we 
can say that this opinion is the opinion of the international community and is 
internationally legitimate. 
 
Can you give an example of the kind of criticism that should be defined as 
racism?
We believe that incitement to religious hatred is a new form of racism. Western 
institutions dealing with Islamophobia are unanimous in saying that the 
phenomenon of Islamophobia is worse than racial discrimination. In practical 
terms, in many instances it is difficult to determine what constitutes 
incitement to religious or racial hatred, which are both proscribed as against 
international human rights. For example, when a Muslim immigrant is 
discriminated against or physically attacked by extremists, the causes could be 
on either racial or religious grounds, or both. The daily attacks, either 
physical or verbal, against Muslims throughout the West are the proof of the 
negative effect of hate speech campaigns which have resulted in an eroding of 
the human rights of those Muslim victims.
 
We should not forget that anti-Semitism, which caused horrendous tragedies for 
European Jews last century, cannot be explained technically or lexically as 
discrimination based solely on race, since the Jews subject to the Holocaust 
were Europeans from different parts of the continent; it was also because of 
their religious affiliation. Within the same context, one should realize that 
the Palestinians, who have been suffering a grave tragedy for the last 60 
years, are ethnically Semitic, but what happens to them is not defined as 
anti-Semitism. What I am saying is that discrimination is discrimination 
whether on religious or racial grounds. I believe we are facing a gross 
campaign of disinformation on the part of some extremist quarters in the West 
and some European politicians who have little understanding of the matter and 
try to exploit the issue for domestic political gain by creating unnecessary 
fear of "the other." 
 
Why should it not be possible to criticize a religion?
In my previous answers, I have tried to explain my views about this. If I may 
elaborate; the criticism of religion has been there for centuries. Trying to 
humiliate, insult others and jeopardize their basic human rights solely over 
their religious beliefs, particularly in the case of Islam, which is followed 
by 1.5 billion people, is understood as an act which falls outside the borders 
of critical dialogue or civilized criticism. 
 
Narrowing down the discussion on the freedom of expression to demanding the 
freedom to be able to denigrate even the most sacred religious values is 
neither civilized nor intellectual. Yet, at the diplomatic level, we are not 
even focusing on this aspect. What we are saying is that incitement to hatred 
should not be allowed, particularly if this specific act constitutes a crime 
within the parameters of international human rights documents. Article 20 of 
the 1966 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights requests 
governments to take measures at the national level against incitement to 
religious hatred.
 
What we are also advocating is that we should all abide not only by domestic 
laws and blasphemy laws, codes of conduct or ethics regulations, if they exist, 
but also by internationally agreed legal instruments. 
 
According to The Washington Post, you recently said that there is a "red line" 
that should not be crossed. What do you mean by that? And what will happen if 
the "red line" is crossed?
I think there has always been, and there should be, a "red line" for any 
irresponsible attitude, whether it is on the individual or group level. Nobody 
can deny that in the exercising of any particular freedom, one should act with 
a sense of responsibility. We might differ on the point where freedom stops and 
responsibility starts. I would like to remind that all legal documents always 
strike a balance between freedoms and responsibility. With regard to the 
freedom of expression, the responsibility starts when there is an act of 
incitement to hatred proscribed by international law. It is important to recall 
that with the provision of freedom under human rights, it is only the freedom 
of expression which is linked with responsibility. 
 
As for the red lines, I would like to say that a national flag, for example, is 
a sacrosanct symbol representing nationhood and sovereignty. Burning a national 
flag is considered a red line forbidden by law even in many Western societies. 
This red line should be respected by others if they want to have cordial 
relations with that nation. If you ask what my position was when Danish flags 
were burnt [after the publication of cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad] and 
diplomatic premises were attacked during demonstrations against Denmark in some 
OIC member states, I reply by saying that I was among the first who condemned 
these incidents as well as the violence surpassing the limits of peaceful 
reactions. 
 
What we are against is not the criticism of religion per se but rather the 
intended objective of this criticism which, in this case, jeopardizes Muslim 
rights by creating an atmosphere of hostility and animosity that makes their 
life unsafe and strewn with prejudice. This is what international law 
prohibits. This would go against the values of living as a globalized human 
family. What humanity is in dire need of is to foster a culture of peace based 
on mutual respect, understanding and dialogue among civilizations and cultures. 
 
http://www.todayszaman.com/tz-web/detaylar.do?load=detay&link=157342


      
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
Ju merrni këtë mesazh sepse jeni të anëtarësuar në grupin "Fjala e Bukur" në 
Google Groups.
Për të dërguar në këtë grup, dërgo email në [email protected]
Për t'u ç'anëtarësuar nga ky grup, dërgo email në [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Për më shumë mundësi, vizito këtë grup në 
http://groups.google.com/group/fjalaebukur
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Antwoord per e-mail aan