Programi i ri i televizionit suedez i udhehequr nga tri muslimane ka ngjallur 
debat te nxehte per normat kulturore dhe integrimin 
 
 
Sweden's new Halal-TV courts controversy
Published: 4 Nov 08 17:33 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.se/15446/20081104/
 
A new programme launched on Monday by Sveriges Television (SVT) featuring three 
young Swedish Muslim women has sparked a heated debate about cultural norms and 
integration.
Controversy about Halal-TV erupted even before the first episode aired on 
Monday night when author and commentator Dilsa Demirbag-Sten, a Kurdish 
immigrant from Turkey who moved to Sweden at the age of six, pointed out that 
one of the show’s hosts had previously said she thought that stoning a woman to 
death was an appropriate punishment for adultery.

While the now 23-year-old Cherin Awad has since distanced herself from the 
comments she made five years ago, that didn’t stop Demirbag-Sten from 
questioning SVT’s decision to have Awad lead a programme about Muslim women in 
Sweden.

“There are many ways for public broadcasting to use high standards of 
journalism to address the diversity issues which affect the Muslim part of the 
population without reducing the group to deeply faithful, headscarf bearing, 
homophobic teetotalers who believe that women should be virgins until they are 
married and support stoning for adultery,” Demirbag-Sten wrote in a column 
published last week in the Svenska Dagbladet (SvD) newspaper.

In addition to Awad, a lawyer, Halal-TV also features 22-year-old doctor-to-be 
Dalia Azzam Kassem and 25-year-old dental hygienist Khadiga El Khabiry, all of 
whom were born in Sweden, but who have roots in different countries in the 
Middle East and North Africa.

The show is meant to show how the three women view their Swedish homeland 
through the lens of their Muslim beliefs. SvD described Halal-TV as a “road 
trip” through Swedish society, with the three lead figures at the wheel which 
ultimately is meant to help deconstruct the often monolithic view of Muslims 
held by many Swedes.

“We are three individuals, and just like a Moderate and a Christian Democrat 
are both alike and different, we also have different opinions. Sometimes our 
views are similar, sometimes we get angry with one another and the programme 
heats up,” Azzam Kassem told SvD.

And the trio didn’t waste any time stirring things up in Halal-TV’s premiere 
episode, which examined class differences through segments filmed in two 
Stockholm suburbs, Danderyd, one of Sweden’s wealthiest, and Botkyra, one of 
the poorest.

In one of the segments, Awad and El Khabiry refuse to shake the hand of 
Aftonbladet newspaper columnist Carl Hamilton, electing instead to greet the 
guest by putting their hands on their chests, leaving Hamilton’s extended hand 
hanging in the air and prompting a sharp exchange.

“I’m sorry, you ought to shake my hand,” said Hamilton, according to a 
transcript published in the Expressen newspaper.

“That’s something I decide,” replied El Khabiry.

“No, I don’t think so!” Hamilton shot back.

The war of words escalated when Azzam Kassem then asked Hamilton what he 
thought a Swede who had converted to Islam ought to do.

“He should shake hands when in Sweden. If he can’t manage that then he can go 
live in a cave and be a hermit,” said Hamilton.

“It’s about how we live as Swedes. That’s how we socialize, we shake hands. 
It’s not we who are the problem. The problem is that you come here and don’t 
want to shake hands, so it’s actually you who are the problem.”

“We didn’t come here. I was born here,” El Khabiry reminded Hamilton.

Writing about the incident on Tuesday in a column in Aftonbladet, Hamilton 
asked, “Is it racist to want to shake hands with a Muslim?”

He further vented his frustration at not being told at the time that the 
exchange had been recorded, highlighting what he saw as the central issue 
behind the handshake controversy.

“Who should adapt to whom? For the hosts of Halal-TV, the answer is obvious. 
The handshaking majority in Sweden should adapt themselves to the 
Muslim-believing-non-handshaking minority,” he writes.

“I don’t have a problem with faithful Muslims or others who don’t want to shake 
hands. On the other hand I have a hard time understanding people who think that 
I’m discriminating against them because I want to greet them as most people are 
greeted in Sweden.”

Considerably fewer viewers, 295,000, tuned in to watch the Halal-TV than the 
400,000 viewers producers had hoped would watch the new programme. 

Reviewing the show in SvD, columnist Annina Rabe said “the confusion was total” 
and criticized the programme for being simplistic, bereft of statistics, and 
not addressing religion at all. 

“Put simply, bad journalism,” she writes. 

David Landes ([EMAIL PROTECTED]/+46 8 656 6518)



      
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
Ju merrni këtë mesazh sepse jeni të anëtarësuar në grupin "Fjala e Bukur" në 
Google Groups.
Për të dërguar në këtë grup, dërgo email në [email protected]
Për t'u ç'anëtarësuar nga ky grup, dërgo email në [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Për më shumë mundësi, vizito këtë grup në 
http://groups.google.com/group/fjalaebukur
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Antwoord per e-mail aan