Author on Islam speaks to Barron Collier High School students
Dalia Mogahed bashkautore(me John Esposition) e “Who Speaks for Islam? What a
Billion Muslims Really Think” foli para nje grupi studentesh ne lidhje me
librin e saj
By KATHERINE LEWIS (Contact)
11:20 p.m., Monday, November 17, 2008
NAPLES — Who speaks for Islam?
Dalia Mogahed did, for a group of Barron Collier High School students.
Mogahed, director of the Gallup Center for Muslim Studies and the co-author of
“Who Speaks for Islam? What a Billion Muslims Really Think,” spoke to the
students on Monday as one of a series of international experts addressing
global issues being made available to area high schools by the Naples Council
on World Affairs. Mogahed also spoke to members of the council later that
afternoon.
Mogahed began her discussion with the students by telling a folktale from the
Middle East about national security and internal relations. Goha traveled back
and forth between two countries and the men at the border were convinced he was
smuggling something. They checked the large baskets on his donkeys each time he
would cross, but came up with nothing.
The border guards asked Goha about the smuggling, telling him they could never
figure out how to do it. Goha told the men that the smuggling was easy. He
smuggled donkeys.
“If you ignore the obvious, it can get you into trouble with national security
and international relations,” she said.
Mogahed said she and co-author John Espositio tried not to ignore the obvious
when writing their book. She said they wanted to bring out the voice of the
silenced majority that was “ignored by the media and overshadowed by a vocal
fringe.”
When she opened the floor for questions, the students wanted to know how
Muslims, including Muslims outside the Middle East, felt about the U.S. They
asked what Muslims outside the U.S. were taught about America and if travel is
safe to the Middle East. They also asked how the tenant of jihad conflicts with
the Koran’s teachings that murder and suicide are wrong.
“You have given me enough to speak about for nine hours,” Mogahed joked.
She began by speaking about the perception that Muslims hate the U.S. because
they hate our freedom. She said the statement was first used by President
George W. Bush about the terrorists shortly after 9/11, but has taken a broader
generalization since then.
“Not all Muslims hate the United States,” she said. “The majority of Muslims in
the Middle East have an unfavorable opinion in the U.S. leadership, but
sub-Saharan Africa has the most favorable opinion of the U.S.”
Mogahed said only 12 percent of Saudi Arabians have a favorable opinion of the
U.S., but that it is more than twice the 5 percent of Spaniards who have a
favorable opinion of the U.S.
She said research shows that Muslims most admire American technology — not only
hardware, but expertise — and the liberty and freedom enjoyed by those in this
country. The one thing that both Americans and Muslims admire least about the
West is the breakdown in the country in terms of family and traditional
culture, she said.
“There are three issues at the root of Muslim anger towards the U.S.,” she
said. “The first is the perception that Muslims are looked down upon. ... The
second is the perception that while we believe in democratic values of
self-determination and human rights, we don’t allow their governments to decide
what values are best for them. .. And third are the acute conflicts — Iraq, the
war in Afghanistan, the conflict between Israel and Palestine in which we are
seen as not having an even-handed role.”
Mogahed said that while 70 percent of Muslims associate terms like ruthless and
arrogant with the U.S., their opinion of Americans is good. Part of that
bridge, she said, has been television.
“They watch what we watch here,” she said. “So what art and culture do is
humanize what politics have demonized.”
Mogahed also spoke about terrorists and what made fringe groups who support
targeting civilians different from the rest of the population that finds
killing civilians morally reprehensible. There was no difference in
religiosity, she said. Instead, the difference had to do with political revenge
and revolution.
Mogahed directly addressed a question brought forward by senior James Carroll,
who wanted to know how the terrorists reconciled murder and suicide with the
tenant of jihad. She said that jihad has two meanings to Muslims. One is a
peaceful struggle within the self to be good and improve society. The other is
a physical, military struggle. She said jihad is different than what the
terrorists are doing.
“It is a foreign word and it is scary,” she said. “But the term jihad means
‘noble warriors’ to a Muslim. That is why it is offensive to Muslims to hear
people call the terrorists jihadists. It is like calling Cuba a democracy
because they think they are. It doesn’t make it true.”
Mogahed said one of the easiest things to do is to change the language to
ensure Americans are not associating something with a community that shouldn’t
be.
“We need to send Muslims the message that America is not the enemy of Islam,”
she said. “Al Qaeda is.”
James, 18, said Mogahed was informative.
“She confirmed and clarified (what I wanted to know),” he said.
Charles Shanks, an international relations teacher at Barron Collier High
School, said he was excited about Mogahed speaking to his students, calling her
book “pivotal.”
“It excites me that my kids can sit down and talk with someone (with
influence),” he said. “We have been privileged to have quite a few speakers
come through these hallways. I think it is very important that they don’t only
hear my voice about these subjects. I believe in showing both sides of the
story. And she was able to talk to them about normal people who live lives the
way we do.”
http://www.naplesnews.com/news/2008/nov/17/author-islam-speaks-barron-collier-high-school-stu/?partner=RSS
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
Ju merrni këtë mesazh sepse jeni të anëtarësuar në grupin "Fjala e Bukur" në
Google Groups.
Për të dërguar në këtë grup, dërgo email në [email protected]
Për t'u ç'anëtarësuar nga ky grup, dërgo email në [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Për më shumë mundësi, vizito këtë grup në
http://groups.google.com/group/fjalaebukur
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---