> But generally, I'd rather have FlashCoders split up into > /more/ lists rather than combining it with FlashNewbies. A > list each for AS2, AS3, FMS, architecture, components and so > on. We could then choose which ones to subscribe to, and > those of us gifted with the seemingly rare ability to set up > email folders could organize them as they please. > For me, personally, that would mean I'd subscribe to all and > collect those I'm not currently interested in in a general > knowledge-base folder for possible later use. That would > reduce the number of mails that I personally consider noise > (although they are perfectly legitimate in a general > FlashCoders list) and thus greatly increase the value the > rest has for me, making me read more of it. I imagine that > would work the same for most.
I understand the theory but unfortunately there's a down-side. For *reading* lists, it's great to have them categorised in this way, but for *posting* to them, it can cause problems. As a Director user, I have quite a few lists to choose from, among which are Dir3d-l, devoted to 3d issues, and dirGames-L, devoted to games programming (in Flash too, incidentally - it's a good list and might benefit from some Flash heads). Now, when I have an issue related to 3d in a games context, which list do I post to to ensure the right people read it? Either I have to choose one or the other, resulting in missing out on some potential advice, or I cross-post, with the result that those who read both lists (a fair proportion) get two copies of the same message. Neither really is ideal. In the end, a general list for experts can be more useful, with a serious naming and shaming of those who post messages with crappy subject lines. I'm not saying the idea is unworkable, but it's worth pointing out what we lose by it. Danny _______________________________________________ [email protected] To change your subscription options or search the archive: http://chattyfig.figleaf.com/mailman/listinfo/flashcoders Brought to you by Fig Leaf Software Premier Authorized Adobe Consulting and Training http://www.figleaf.com http://training.figleaf.com
