I think the search for a good logo is a great start and it is something that should help the community to build upon. Most candidates seem to be crafted by professionals that do identify themselves with the framework. I have not been there to vote in the first round and would probably have picked something else. Still I like both candidates. Although 59 looks a bit like someone put a chainsaw to cut the F off :-) but in a way that is also true. I agree with Tomasz that after the finish there should be a second level discussion about the general identity .. a logo alone is not enough .. lots of things can be adapted..
On Jan 24, 2012, at 1:55 PM, Tomasz Maciąg | Fuse Collective wrote: > I've already wrote this but accidentally in "[VOTE] Logo contest round #2". > Iit could get lost between voting messages so I'm posting here again. > > I'm very pleased that our logo made to the second round but I assumed there > will be some sort of discussion after round 1. > I've imagined that people could express their feelings about selected logos > (what they like, what they don't like or what they want to see) and based on > that input we could work on our logo. > Additionally branding is not just logo so I thought that we could take some > time to work on more complete branding presentation, with different logo > variations, additional materials (e.g. t-shirts), may be key visual, example > presentation on different use case scenarios (to discuss where and how the > logo could be used by community or others). That could be later put to vote. > Voting already started, things are now in motion but I think this should be > considered on todo list for winning logo... > > W dniu 2012-01-24 08:13, David Arno pisze: >>> From: Doug Arthur [mailto:[email protected]] >>> Sent: 23 January 2012 23:38 >>> >>> Remember, PPMC members votes are the final say, and ultimately, >>> that will be the what final decision becomes, but the community votes >>> help the PPMC members make their decisions, >>> One specific concern was how #49 appeared to some of the PPMC members, >>> and feeling that some users could look at the logo as negative. >> It's great that the PPMC members are seeking the opinions of the community, >> but care needs to be taken over how that is done. Cynical people might read >> what you wrote as "the PPMC likes #42. The community voted for #49. Bearing >> in mind the negatives of #49, could the community re-vote please. Unless you >> overwhelmingly choose #49 though, the PPMC will choose #42 regardless of the >> result." If I were the designer of #49, I'd be pretty pee'd off over the >> biased tone of the announcement. >> >> Being a bloody-minded person at heart, even though I prefer #42, I'm tempted >> to vote for #49 just to counter the bias... >> >> David. >> > > -- > Tomasz Maciąg > > t: +48 516 615 881 > e: [email protected] > > Fuse Collective Sp. z o.o. > Plac Wolności 12 > 91-415 Łódź > POLAND > > t: +48 42 2920753 > f: +48 42 2920758 > > [email protected] > www.fusecollective.com > > Sąd Rejonowy dla Łodzi-Śródmieścia w Łodzi, XX Wydział KRS: 0000358321 > > NIP: 7252023978, Regon: 100883396. Wysokość kapitału zakładowego: 10.000,00 zl > > -- > Informacja zawarta w tej wiadomości ma charakter poufny i objęta jest > tajemnicą zawodową. Wiadomość jest skierowana wyłącznie do osoby, która jest > wymieniona w polu adresata. > Jeżeli osoba, która otrzymała mail, nie jest jego adresatem lub > przedstawicielem adresata, to niniejszym zostaje ona powiadomiona, że > zapoznanie się z treścią, rozpowszechnianie lub kopiowanie tego maila albo > zawartych w nim informacji jest zakazane. W wypadku, gdy wiadomość została > otrzymana przez niewłaściwą osobę, uprzejmie proszę o natychmiastowe > powiadomienie o tym fakcie nadawcy i zniszczenie dokumentu. Jeśli niniejsza > wiadomość stanowi, lub zawiera jakikolwiek utwór w rozumieniu ustawy o prawie > autorskim i prawach pokrewnych, pozostaje on pod ochroną jej przepisów i nie > może zostać w jakikolwiek sposób wykorzystany. > > > This e-mail may contain confidential and/or privileged information. If you > are not the intended recipient (or have received this e-mail in error) please > notify the sender immediately and delete this e-mail. Any unauthorized > copying, disclosure or distribution of the material in this e-mail is > strictly forbidden. >
