Joseph, I don't see any flaws in your assessment, though INAL either. LGPL libraries can certainly be compatible with Fluid's licensing practices, but I wouldn't just use LGPL code without some analysis of how you're using it. In the Sakai / Kuali projects there are a number of licenses that we've become comfortable with and permit the use of with some simple instructions on how to document the use, and make sure the appropriate license and/or attribution are documented. With LGPL we go into a bit more depth of discussion on how the library is used so we can assess whether our use falls into Section 6 of the LGPL - "A work that uses the library."
It's a bit more complicated for you because you have to make sure that your use of LGPL is compatible with both of your outbound license choices... BSD and ECL 2.0. We generally have a brief conversation with an attorney to make sure we're using it in a way that's compatible. A few questions almost always come up... Is the Fluid project modifying the library (jAria)? Or using it as is? If you are modifying it, are you doing it through the jAria project and then essentially using it "as is" or is it uniquely modified? /chris -- the rSmart group Chris Coppola | 602.490.0472 blog: coppola.rsmart.com On Mar 5, 2008, at 11:52 AM, Joseph Scheuhammer wrote: > Chris, > > Regarding (2) the Fluid licence, that's not right. Fluid is dual > licenced under BSD and ECL 2.0: > http://source.fluidproject.org/svn/LICENSE.txt > >> The question is, in order to be used by the Fluid project, does the >> jAria plugin need to be changed to the GPL/MIT dual license? >> > > Short answer: no. But, I am not a lawyer either. As far as I > know, the LGPL is compatible with Fluid's licensing policy -- Fluid > can link to the jAria code, it can re-distibute the code, and, I > believe is legally allowed to contribute to it (that is, contribute > to an LGPL'ed project). > > Your question is possibly, although unlikely, more apropos jQuery in > the sense of whether jQuery plugins must be licensed in the same way > as jQuery itself (which is the dual MIT/GPL licence). I think LGPL > is sufficient for that as well (it's compatible). > > -- > ;;;;joseph > > 'This is not war -- this is pest control!' > - "Doomsday", Dalek Leader - > _______________________________________________ fluid-work mailing list fluid-work@fluidproject.org http://fluidproject.org/mailman/listinfo/fluid-work
