Jan,

I've just went to update my version of PSPad and things where not quite as I
expected given your previous decision ...

cite:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Because I got many complains last few months, I made final decision
already.
Next PSPad version (download links from PSPad site) will be free of bundled
software.--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


>From your download page, at http://www.pspad.com/en/download.php, the top four
icons link to

* http://www.fosshub.com/PSPad.html
* http://www.download3k.com/Install-PSPad-editor.html
* http://www.fosshub.com/PSPad.html
* http://www.pspad.tk/pspad/pspad459en.zip

You correctly wrote
cite:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am responsible for download links on PSpad.com page. I can't be
responsible for any other link on the 
web.--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


But you are also responsible for the links on pspad.com that direct a user to a
third party file hosting site. Those fosshub links remain.

I'd suggest:

* You ought completely dissociate yourself from fosshub given their prior dirty
practices (I have no experience with download3K but I'm not inclined to trust
them); 
* Host only with reputable third party sites, if you must use third party sites
at all (github?); 
* For downloadables that you host yourself, host them at pspad.com, not pspad.tk
(this seems dodgy even though, I assume, you have ordinary reasons for doing it
that way); 
* Provide an installer, as well as a zip, that you host yourself; 
* Redesign your download page to more clearly differentiate icons that link to
third party download sites from those that are self-hosted, if you must use
third party hosting sites.

[email protected] noted
cite:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
... All of the companies I have worked with have software security
policies which are being constantly reviewed, and all now preclude installation
of anything which may be associated with malware 
..--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


... those are companies with sound policies. While PSpad remains associated with
fosshub, pspad remains "associated with malware".

However, it is clear that you've taken action to improve things by providing a
digitally signed installer (with Comodo), even where hosted on a bad site like
fosshub.

So I tested that installer myself, from fosshub. I verified the certificate and
ran the installer. I can confirm that no intermediate screens appeared in the
wizard, inviting the installation of secondary software. So far everything looks
good.

So even though I don't think you've quite met the spirit under which I promised
my donation, you have taken steps to ensure users can get a clean installation
of pspad. So you should have received a USD 25 donation from me (a little more
than the €20 promised).

If you implement all of my previous suggestions, you'll get another USD 25, when
I next upgrade.

Thanks for your continued development of one of the best text editors.

- John

-- 
<http://forum.pspad.com/read.php?2,59900,65433>
PSPad freeware editor http://www.pspad.com

Odpovedet emailem