This message is from the T13 list server.

Dear T13 Committee:

I forgot a CFA committee liaison item at last weeks meeting. The CFA is
encountering problems with software that does not conform to the ATA
specification. CFA devices set 848Ah in Identify word 0 to indicate 
that they are CFA cards. The value is not supposed to be interpreted 
bit-wise but some software does. Incorrectly determining that the media is 

always removable, the application blocks booting. The CFA would like CFA 
devices to be able to report codes other than 848Ah and still be 
ATA/ATAPI standard. 

This sounds like a good idea to me. 

The requested change is listed below. If there are no objections I will 
ask
the editor to make the change and then we can vote on it in December. I 
will 
also add a standing CFA liaison report item to our agenda. 


In section: 
6.16.9 Word 0: General configuration

The Compact Flash Association would like T13 to change the wording in 
ATA/ATAPI-7 from

   Devices supporting the CFA feature set shall place the value
   848Ah in word 0. In this case, the above definitions for the
   bits in word 0 are not valid.

to

   Devices reporting a value of 848Ah in this word shall support
   the CFA feature set.  In this case, the above definitions for
   the bits in word 0 are not valid.

Best Regards,
Daniel J. Colegrove
Hitachi Global Storage Technologies

[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(702) 614-6119

Reply via email to