> Recently a friend of mine submitted a comment on the blogpost about "9 > reasons women don't edit.." > While I understand it's Sue's personal blog and therefore the > expectations of transparency and openness are not the same as with a true > Wikimedia blog, but her post was rejected by moderation. > I acknowledge she raised several controversial points, and possibly > mistaken. however she's quite direct and frank at expressing her ideas, > which may cause them to come across as non politically correct.. > She has this feeling that her comment was rejected not due to form but > due to substance, that the statements made Sue uncomfortable and tried to > hid it. I try to assure her that's not the case, that it was a sort of > misunderstanding. > In any case, I promised her to repost the comment here (in case comment > got moderated by a third person and Sue never got the chance to see it or > reply). > > ----- Begin post ----Sue, can you please explain how the Foundation will > change the wikipedia culture without any involvement of the communities > in this change? > Sorry to point at the emperor's new clothes but, AFAIK this initiative is > not a grassroots initiative coming from the communities, but something > coming from the outside and driven by (sorry to sound unrespectful) paid > staff, and very well paid (it reminds me a lot to the last member of the > wikipedia paid staff, Larry Sanger, trying to tell communities how they > should behave...), and not by leader wikipedians (sorry Sue, but you're a > mediocre wikipedian, with less than two hundred editions). > The problem you point out is real. The alleged reasons behind that > problem are a clear sample of amateurism. Coming here, cherry picking > among the mails you've received and trying to come out with a conclusion > is low-quality original research. I understand that the WMF has to > justify somehow why most of the money donated to wikipedia goes actually > to pay salaries of people that is unable to do anything for the > communities and not to the maintenance of the project. And last but not > least, try to say English Wikipedia whenever you now say Wikipedia. The > Wikipedia projects are far more than the English Wikipedia. Best regards > --- end post ---
You make some good points, but err in several respect: We don't, and can't limit hiring to seasoned Wikipedians, and there are quite a few seasoned Wikipedians who are behind Sue with respect to this issue. As to the 9 reasons, they express peoples' feelings about editing; they are not close examinations of editing history. The feelings are real too, even if close examination of a specific controversy may show only a failure to impose one's will and being upset about it. Fred _______________________________________________ foundation-l mailing list [email protected] Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l
