You obviously don't get it David so I'm done with this conversation. Roger D. WilsonFilm Scientist613 324 - [email protected]http://www.rogerdwilson.ca Without failure you can never achieve success. I have based my process and my career as an experimental film artist on this statement; and I welcome it as it pushes me forward as an artist to try something different, something new.
> From: [email protected] > Date: Sun, 27 Apr 2014 19:26:58 -0700 > To: [email protected] > Subject: Re: [Frameworks] Advice with screening format for festival. Help! > > Roger: > > If you feel "cut down" or "shot down" because someone disagrees with you on a > Listserv, you might want to grow a thicker skin. > > > I gave an example from my own experience as an artist who has had his > > worked projected through a film projector and a video projector. > > Which you admitted was a "low end" projector. From this, you generalized to > the claim that only film projection looks "like film." I said this is false, > because it is false. Framing the claim as beyond critique because it's an > "opinion" is utter BS. It may also be your "opinion" that the Earth is only > 6,000 years old and humans and dinosaurs inhabited the planet at the same > time. Some opinions are worth more than others, based on the argument and > evidence one can muster in support of them. You reply is an ad hominem attack > on me for having the effrontery to disagree with you on substance, and you > made no response whatsoever to the substantive points in my post. > > > I find this discussion board has a lot of members who criticize other > > filmmakers for the suggestions they offer to artists looking for advice. > > Well, anyone who advises an artist with limited resources in terms of funds, > and facing a very tight deadline to have a 35mm print made, or go to the > effort of making a DIY contact print on a Steenbeck, deserves to be > criticized. > > > The film screened last night at a local venue and their 35mm projector > > broke down > > I guess that venue hadn't read Scott Dorsey's post asserting "It's hard to > mess up a 35mm presentation." > > > I have 20 plus years working in the film industry and working with film to > > create my own films. My opinion matters as much as any one else on this > > discussion board. > > I'm confused. Is your "opinion" supposed to be considered valid for others > because of your 20-plus years experience, or merely a purely subjective > evaluation because it's JUST "your opinion"? (FYI, I've been doing moving > picture work for over 40 years, but that doesn't automatically make my > opinion worth spit.) > > And, oh yeah, I noticed that neat little inflation where you tried to infer > from my objection to ONE SPECIFIC FACTUAL CLAIM made in your OP that I > somehow am am discounting you and ALL your opinions categorically. In > general, in their collectivity, yeah, everyone's opinions matter. But if > 'being professional' means no one call out a particular claim as crapola as > long as the author has couched it under the weaselly rubric of 'what I > believe,' then I believe I shall have to maintain my amateur standing. > > djt > > > _______________________________________________ > FrameWorks mailing list > [email protected] > https://mailman-mail5.webfaction.com/listinfo/frameworks
_______________________________________________ FrameWorks mailing list [email protected] https://mailman-mail5.webfaction.com/listinfo/frameworks
