Here's my review of the third film in the Lord of the Rings trilogy, "Return of the King." I was able to see it at a screening yesterday. A few people told me they are having trouble reading these messages, because apparently when I write in Word it embeds certain formats; when I send it out by AOL I don't see them, but some email programs do and turn those cues into gibberish. Sorry. An alternative is, everything I send out goes onto the archives page of teh mailing list, and you can read it there "clean" of format.The URL for the archives is :  I was also thinking that I could send it as an attached file as well as pasted in, but don't know if that's a problem for recipients.

What becomes a legend most? The old answer, âfur,â wouldnât be as popular today as it was when Blackglama mink draped legendary stars like Lauren Bacall in a glamorous ad campaign. What makes something a legend, a classic, is not easy to identify, but the âLord of the Ringsâ trilogy has got it, hands down. âThe Return of the Kingâ is a crowning conclusion to the trilogy, and also arguably the best of the three films, though none are disappointments. Thatâs something that canât be said of most movie-sequel series.


People know immediately that âThe Lord of the Ringsâ trilogy is historically significant and will have lasting value through future generations. Itâs a classic. Itâs not till we go on to say, âLikeââ that we realize there is no obvious work to compare it with.  When have we seen something like this before? The Star Wars series is not of such consistent quality, and in its shallower moments seems a Patty-Duke cousin to Star Trek. Films set in outer space may always be doomed to Jetsonsâ syndrome, premised on speculation that will sound arbitrary or even silly with the passage of time. Outer-space films will inevitably lack gravity, you might say, though Iâd advise against it.


Others films at the top of anybodyâs âclassicâ list are often character studies (âCitizen Kane,â âThe Graduateâ), or vigorous entertainment of the action, musical, or tear-jerker variety (âWizard of Oz,â âGone With the Windâ). To get the trilogyâs combination of profundity, emotion, and astonishing spectacle you almost always have to have a war movie--âLawrence of Arabiaâ or âSaving Private Ryan,â though neither is as comprehensive as LOTR.


It helps that J.R.R. Tolkein created a legend to begin with, from its furry hobbit toes upward. Director Peter Jackson realized this material impeccably, with the best music, casting, and effects available. In this concluding film of the trilogy all the elements previously set in motion come together in perfect synchronization, without the occasional drag of the second film.


In that film, for example, the battle scenes were sometimes wearying--too many tiny figures clashing on a giant screen. In âReturn of the Kingâ the battles feature larger elements that are easier to track visually. The city of Gondor, a mountainside tower of flat-white stone glaring against the charcoal-gray sky, defends itself by launching giant chunks of masonry against the orcs, which land with the impact of a tossed elephant. The enemy has, not elephants, but oliphaunts, a beast the size of an aircraft hangar with bristling tusks. Each oliphaunt bears a wooden tower manned by dozens of archers, and when one of those goes down, itâs a sight to behold. (The elf Legolasâ acrobatic defeat of an oliphaunt brought an outburst of applause from the screening audience.) The winged Nazgul wheel overhead emitting unbearable screams. You can tell because the characters onscreen are clapping their hands over their ears in pain, but thanks to the miracle of modern sound recording technology, the audience doesnât have to do the same.


A âbigâ classic film has big fight scenes. It also has courageous characters banding together, and in âReturn of the Kingâ we see members of the original fellowship further separated from each other, to the point of fearful isolation, and then brought satisfyingly together again. Itâs necessary that such a story show the charactersâ fallibility and fear, or else the courage seems to have no cost. Quiet doubting or despairing moments visit several of the characters, memorably when Pippin is required to sing a Shire song in a foreign land, and this hobbit who was hitherto a clown lifts his voice in a poignant ode. Most striking, however (PLOT SPOILER AHEAD) is the moment when Frodo has arrived at Mt. Doom and prepares to complete his quest by throwing the evil ring into the flames--and changes his mind. Its power over him has grown so strong that he declares he will keep it instead, and puts the ring on, becoming instantly invisible. (ALL CLEAR) We feel Samâs astonishment and helplessness at that moment.


The effect on Frodo is lasting, and in the concluding scenes he retains a brooding, troubled quality. This is what saves the film from being too sweet; itâs what preserves a quality of mystery. Tolkein wrote to his publisher: âMy work has escaped from my control. I have produced a monsterâa complex, rather bitter, and rather terrifying romance.â


What becomes a legend is a story that is made out of elements already within us: awareness of a great battle that is going on, that involves us somehow already, as well as invisible powers far stronger than us; the need for others to help us in this journey, and a love for them in all their failings; a sense of our own capacity to turn traitor at the last moment, despite our high-flown claims. All of these are elements of the Gospel story, the story weâre born carrying inside, âThe Greatest Story Ever Toldâ as it was called in a movie that used to be considered a classic. Such overt presentations of the Gospel have no traction in our current culture and provoke ridicule instead. The story has to go underground and come up from Middle Earth for a modern audience to embrace it in disguise. Thatâs how a story becomes a legend, and a great film of such a legend becomes an enduring classic.

Frederica Mathewes-Green
Frederica-l mailing list
*** Please address all replies to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] ***
You can check your subscription information here:

Reply via email to