On 2025-10-16 23:06, Lexi Winter wrote:
Chris wrote in <[email protected]>:On 2025-10-15 05:16, Lexi Winter wrote: > so if dhclient use in jails is widespread, we should probably > add it to minimal-jail. IMHO isn't the HOST responsible for routing? Doesn't that make dhclient and friends somewhat unusual (not average jail(8) setup?).no, in VNET jails the jail does routing itself, including IP address assignment. while i personally prefer to do this statically, i believe it's fairly common to use DHCP (for IPv4) or SLAAC (for IPv6) to handle this automatically, especially in mass-hosting setups. since dhclient is fairly small (150kB) and DHCP is something people typically expect to "just work", i am leaning on the side of putting this into minimal-jail unless anyone has a strong objection.
No objection here. Just didn't seem like a very common jail need from my perspective. But now that you mention it. I can easily see it's value. Thanks, Lexi. -- There is no such place as the internet
0xE512722F.asc
Description: application/pgp-keys
