Hi Bart, fine to move the discussion into the public. I thought
it would be a good idea to have your answer as the first post
(makes the thread 1 mail shorter)...

So you tell us: if mkdosfs fails to init hidden sectors (partition
position) and geometry (heads, sectors), only the BOOT process will
have a problem. OKAY. Then we are back at the discussion: Should SYS
fix this a) automatically b) on user request or c) never ?

The OTHER problem is occassional overwriting of FAT32 boot sectors
with a) directory entries or b) the filesystem info sector. Maybe
both are related to bugs in older FORMAT versions. However, I really
do need feeback from people who run FORMAT under Win98-DOS and use
FAT32 partitions (either formatted by Win or by FreeDOS FORMAT, either
under FreeDOS or Win kernel) with either Win98 or FreeDOS whether any
combination still causes the problem with Win98 / FORMAT 0.91n ...

Even the "failed to treat cluster numbers right" bug in the kernel should
not cause FreeDOS to use the boot sector as directory - maybe THAT is a
Win98 "bug" if the filesystem info sector position is initialized to 0
by older FORMAT versions. As told, I cannot reproduce (no Win98), so not
sure whether FreeDOS or Win98 does the actual boot sector trashing. The
FreeDOS cluster number bug which you mention WOULD be an explanation for
FreeDOS seeing no root directory on FAT32 drives sometimes, though.

I would really be happy about FORMAT x: /D /V:test logs, COPYBS (of SYSLINUX)
boot sector information, MS SCANDISK output, DOS / Linux dosfsck output,
anything like that. Maybe in Win98 some bug only gets triggered after a
reboot or if the root directory reaches a certain size. So feel free to test
that, too. If you have some test results ready, please let me know the rough
results first. I can then tell you which parts of which logfiles I need.

Thanks!


Eric.


-------------------------------------------------------
The SF.Net email is sponsored by EclipseCon 2004
Premiere Conference on Open Tools Development and Integration
See the breadth of Eclipse activity. February 3-5 in Anaheim, CA.
http://www.eclipsecon.org/osdn
_______________________________________________
Freedos-kernel mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-kernel

Reply via email to