Hi! This indeed is a fun topic. CF "disks" are supposed to
understand IDE and you can have purely mechanical adapters
to use them with IDE controllers in your PC. But be aware
that CF were originally popular in good digital photographic,
so they are tuned towards writing a few, large files during
a photoshoot, not for accessing many small files in DOS.

I have tried to use a CF for temp files in Linux 10+ years ago
with two goals: Give the mechanical harddisk the opportunity
to spin down and save noise and energy and gain some speed.

Neither of the goals really worked out. I had to kick a lot
of apps and things to stop writing temp files to other places
to get any resting periods for the harddisk and the CF often
was slower than the harddisk for typical temp file activities,
or it had to pause to do some bookkeeping once in a while.

So do not expect spectacular results in DOS, but it still is
fun to have a small memory card as DOS "harddisk" without big
efforts. Well. If your CF properly boots. And if your CF does
not self-identify as "could be swapped any moment like floppy
disks" or anything like that. So things can still happen which
confuse your BIOS or DOS, but it might just as well work :-)

Robert has tried a few CF brands recently, so he will probably
answer your question with more recent experiences than me :-)

Regarding your Linux: On a modern computer, you probably want
to use a RAM filesystem for temporary files. But you say you
need a lot of swap, so this is probably no option for you. I
can predict that if your swap is on CF, your Linux will be at
least as slow as it was with a harddisk ;-)

I would not worry too much about wearing out the CF: The swap
is small compared to the total size of the CF and often it is
how much you write in terms of multiples of total disk size
which determines how long your flash media will work.

Based on Robert's recent comments, I do not think that it will
be a problem to acquire enough CF cards, in case you worry to
wear them out too soon. If you want something more durable,
you could probably invest into SD card adapters, although it
will be more indirect - SD does not speak IDE, so the adapter
has to have some built-in intelligence, unlike for CF to IDE.
I have some adapters which just plug to one end of the IDE
cable, but there also are adapters to plug directly into a
mainboard. In both cases, you probably also need power, via
floppy or harddisk style power connectors for example. You
could probably just glue the adapter to some cardboard and
stick that to a drive bay so things are not falling around?

Regards, Eric



_______________________________________________
Freedos-user mailing list
Freedos-user@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/freedos-user

Reply via email to