Hey Peter, I put up a new release that hopefully outputs better/right error messages.
http://download.gluster.com/pub/freeipmi/qa-release/freeipmi-0.8.12.beta2.tar.gz Thanks, Al On Wed, 2010-11-17 at 14:15 -0800, Al Chu wrote: > Hey Peter, > > On Wed, 2010-11-17 at 14:05 -0800, Peter Selby wrote: > > That works! > > > > Checking out the config, I get: > > > > Section Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege > > ## Possible values: > > Unused/User/Operator/Administrator/OEM_Proprietary > > Maximum_Privilege_Cipher_Suite_Id_0 OEM_Proprietary > > ## Possible values: > > Unused/User/Operator/Administrator/OEM_Proprietary > > Maximum_Privilege_Cipher_Suite_Id_1 OEM_Proprietary > > ## Possible values: > > Unused/User/Operator/Administrator/OEM_Proprietary > > ## Maximum_Privilege_Cipher_Suite_Id_2 > > ## Possible values: > > Unused/User/Operator/Administrator/OEM_Proprietary > > ## Maximum_Privilege_Cipher_Suite_Id_3 > > EndSection > > This is good, exactly what I hoped would happen. > > > When committing, any uncommented line gives: > > > > ERROR: Failed to commit > > `Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege:Maximum_Privilege_Cipher_Suite_Id_0': Field > > Required > > > > ...Regardless of setting. Is that an error, or is the field just read-only? > > Doh! I need to fix the error message text, but the basic behavior is > correct. The other two fields: > > Maximum_Privilege_Cipher_Suite_Id_2 > and > Maximum_Privilege_Cipher_Suite_Id_2 > > need to be populated with a value (and the line uncommented). Hopefully > that will be enough to get around the HP problem (if there's a further > HP mobo problem, we'll have to deal with it when we find it). > > Al > > > Thanks again! > > > > Peter > > > > On Wed, Nov 17, 2010 at 11:26 AM, Al Chu <[email protected]> wrote: > > > Hi Peter, > > > > > > http://download.gluster.com/pub/freeipmi/qa-release/freeipmi-0.8.12.beta1.tar.gz > > > > > > I realized the workaround in beta0 fixed the --checkout part for this > > > issue on your motherboard, but I had a bug in the --commit portion of > > > the workaround. Could you check out the above instead? Thanks. > > > > > > Al > > > > > > On Tue, 2010-11-16 at 17:23 -0800, Al Chu wrote: > > >> Hi Peter, > > >> > > >> I believe I have something that should workaround your problem, can you > > >> try out this test tar.gz to see? Without a motherboard to try this on, > > >> I don't know if it works for sure, but I'm confident it will. The > > >> tar.gz is here; > > >> > > >> http://download.gluster.com/pub/freeipmi/qa-release/freeipmi-0.8.12.beta0.tar.gz > > >> > > >> It is quite newer than what you were running before, hope that's ok. > > >> > > >> Normal ./configure ; make ; make install to install, or you can run > > >> bmc-config out of the local build bmc-config/src/. > > >> > > >> If it doesn't work, please send the --debug output like before. > > >> > > >> Thanks, > > >> Al > > >> > > >> On Mon, 2010-11-15 at 21:34 -0800, Peter Selby wrote: > > >> > Thanks! Let me know if you need any more info... > > >> > > > >> > On Mon, Nov 15, 2010 at 4:10 PM, Al Chu <[email protected]> wrote: > > >> > > Hi Peter, > > >> > > > > >> > > It's as I suspected: > > >> > > > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get LAN Configuration Parameters Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = present_revision[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = oldest_revision_parameter[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 4h] = cipher_suite_entry_count[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved[ 4b] > > >> > > > > >> > > This says there are 4 cipher suites to read. > > >> > > > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get LAN Configuration Parameters Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = present_revision[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = oldest_revision_parameter[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = cipher_suite_id_entry_A[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = cipher_suite_id_entry_B[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cipher_suite_id_entry_C[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 3h] = cipher_suite_id_entry_D[ 8b] > > >> > > > > >> > > This shows which ones are supported, and it properly shows 4 of them. > > >> > > > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get LAN Configuration Parameters Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = present_revision[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = oldest_revision_parameter[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 55h] = reserved[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 5h] = maximum_privilege_for_cipher_suite_1[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 5h] = maximum_privilege_for_cipher_suite_2[ 4b] > > >> > >> fiid_obj_get: maximum_privilege_for_cipher_suite_3: no data set > > >> > > > > >> > > This is supposed to tell us what the maximum privilege level for > > >> > > those 4 > > >> > > cipher suites are, but the command only returns 2. Uh oh ... > > >> > > > > >> > > I'll need to think about how to work around this. Maybe if this > > >> > > happens, I could have bmc-config output "Unknown" or something, and > > >> > > it's > > >> > > up to the user to force the configuration of something. Let me think > > >> > > about this and get back to you with a patch ... > > >> > > > > >> > > Al > > >> > > > > >> > > On Mon, 2010-11-15 at 16:00 -0800, Peter Selby wrote: > > >> > >> Thanks for the quick response! > > >> > >> > > >> > >> ipmiping doesn't work, either from the host or from a neighbour. > > >> > >> I'm > > >> > >> pretty sure it's not a network issue, but I'll double-check, and > > >> > >> try a > > >> > >> hard-reset. > > >> > >> > > >> > >> Here's the output of debug: > > >> > >> > > >> > >> bmc-config --checkout --section=Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege --debug > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get Device ID Request > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 1h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get Device ID Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 1h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = device_id[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 3h] = device_revision.revision[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = device_revision.reserved1[ 3b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = device_revision.sdr_support[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = firmware_revision1.major_revision[ 7b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = firmware_revision1.device_available[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 22h] = firmware_revision2.minor_revision[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = ipmi_version_major[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = ipmi_version_minor[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = additional_device_support.sensor_device[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = > > >> > >> additional_device_support.sdr_repository_device[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = additional_device_support.sel_device[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = > > >> > >> additional_device_support.fru_inventory_device[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = > > >> > >> additional_device_support.ipmb_event_receiver[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = > > >> > >> additional_device_support.ipmb_event_generator[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = additional_device_support.bridge[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = additional_device_support.chassis_device[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ F85h] = manufacturer_id.id[20b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = manufacturer_id.reserved1[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = product_id[16b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get Channel Info Command Request > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 42h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved[ 4b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get Channel Info Command Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 42h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = actual_channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = actual_channel_number.reserved[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = channel_medium_type[ 7b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = channel_medium_type.reserved[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = channel_protocol_type[ 5b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = channel_protocol_type.reserved[ 3b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = active_session_count[ 6b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = session_support[ 2b] > > >> > >> [ 1BF2h] = vendor_id[24b] > > >> > >> [ FFFFh] = auxiliary_channel_info[16b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get Channel Info Command Request > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 42h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved[ 4b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get Channel Info Command Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 42h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ CCh] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = actual_channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = actual_channel_number.reserved[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = channel_medium_type[ 7b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = channel_medium_type.reserved[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = channel_protocol_type[ 5b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = channel_protocol_type.reserved[ 3b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = active_session_count[ 6b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = session_support[ 2b] > > >> > >> [ 1BF2h] = vendor_id[24b] > > >> > >> [ FFFFh] = auxiliary_channel_info[16b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get Channel Info Command Request > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 42h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved[ 4b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get Channel Info Command Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 42h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = actual_channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = actual_channel_number.reserved[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 4h] = channel_medium_type[ 7b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = channel_medium_type.reserved[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = channel_protocol_type[ 5b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = channel_protocol_type.reserved[ 3b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = active_session_count[ 6b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = session_support[ 2b] > > >> > >> [ 1BF2h] = vendor_id[24b] > > >> > >> [ FFFFh] = auxiliary_channel_info[16b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get User Access Command Request > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 44h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved1[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = user_id[ 6b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved2[ 2b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get User Access Command Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 44h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 3h] = max_channel_user_ids[ 6b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved1[ 2b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = current_channel_user_ids[ 6b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = user_id_enable_status[ 2b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = current_channel_fixed_names[ 6b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved2[ 2b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = user_privilege_level_limit[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = user_ipmi_messaging[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = user_link_authentication[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = user_restricted_to_callback[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved3[ 1b] > > >> > >> # > > >> > >> # Section Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege Comments > > >> > >> # > > >> > >> # If your system supports IPMI 2.0 and Serial-over-LAN (SOL),cipher > > >> > >> suite IDs > > >> > >> # may be configurable below. In the Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege > > >> > >> section, maximum > > >> > >> # user privilege levels allowed for authentication under IPMI 2.0 > > >> > >> (including > > >> > >> # Serial-over-LAN) are set for each supported cipher suite ID. Each > > >> > >> cipher suite > > >> > >> # ID supports different sets of authentication, integrity, and > > >> > >> encryption > > >> > >> # algorithms for IPMI 2.0. Typically, the highest privilege level > > >> > >> any username > > >> > >> # configured should set for support under a cipher suite ID. This > > >> > >> is typically > > >> > >> # "Administrator". > > >> > >> # > > >> > >> Section Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get LAN Configuration Parameters Request > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved1[ 3b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = get_parameter[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 16h] = parameter_selector[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = set_selector[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = block_selector[ 8b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get LAN Configuration Parameters Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = present_revision[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = oldest_revision_parameter[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 4h] = cipher_suite_entry_count[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved[ 4b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get LAN Configuration Parameters Request > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved1[ 3b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = get_parameter[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 17h] = parameter_selector[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = set_selector[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = block_selector[ 8b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get LAN Configuration Parameters Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = present_revision[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = oldest_revision_parameter[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = cipher_suite_id_entry_A[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = cipher_suite_id_entry_B[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cipher_suite_id_entry_C[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 3h] = cipher_suite_id_entry_D[ 8b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get LAN Configuration Parameters Request > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 2h] = channel_number[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = reserved1[ 3b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = get_parameter[ 1b] > > >> > >> [ 18h] = parameter_selector[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = set_selector[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = block_selector[ 8b] > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> Get LAN Configuration Parameters Response > > >> > >> ===================================================== > > >> > >> [ 2h] = cmd[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 0h] = comp_code[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = present_revision[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 1h] = oldest_revision_parameter[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 55h] = reserved[ 8b] > > >> > >> [ 5h] = maximum_privilege_for_cipher_suite_1[ 4b] > > >> > >> [ 5h] = maximum_privilege_for_cipher_suite_2[ 4b] > > >> > >> fiid_obj_get: maximum_privilege_for_cipher_suite_3: no data set > > >> > >> > > >> > >> On Mon, Nov 15, 2010 at 3:55 PM, Al Chu <[email protected]> wrote: > > >> > >> > Hi Peter, > > >> > >> > > > >> > >> > Assuming you're using a recent version of FreeIPMI, there's > > >> > >> > probably > > >> > >> > some IPMI non-compliance going on on your motherboard. The short > > >> > >> > guess > > >> > >> > is that the motherboard isn't properly reporting things to > > >> > >> > bmc-config > > >> > >> > correctly, and bmc-config gets confused and gives up. There's > > >> > >> > been a > > >> > >> > few IPMI issues for the HP DL145 already reported to me. Lets see > > >> > >> > if we > > >> > >> > can figure out what's going on. Can you send me the --debug > > >> > >> > output. > > >> > >> > Since the problem appears just in that section, how about running > > >> > >> > this > > >> > >> > to shorten the output > > >> > >> > > > >> > >> > bmc-config --checkout --section=Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege --debug > > >> > >> > > > >> > >> >> Any idea what could be wrong, or how to fix it? And could this > > >> > >> >> be the > > >> > >> >> reason the network won't come up? > > >> > >> > > > >> > >> > Although it's always possible, it's unlikely this is the cause of > > >> > >> > IPMI > > >> > >> > over LAN not working. Can you get an ipmiping > > >> > >> > (/usr/sbin/ipmiping) to > > >> > >> > work? If yes that would point to it being an authentication > > >> > >> > problem > > >> > >> > (e.g. username/password/privilege, etc.), if no, possibly a more > > >> > >> > basic > > >> > >> > networking issue (subnetting, routing, etc.). > > >> > >> > > > >> > >> > I haven't played with this motherboard specifically, but a few > > >> > >> > recent > > >> > >> > ones I've encountered require you to hard-reset (e.g. power > > >> > >> > button push) > > >> > >> > the motherboard for configuration changes to "stick". It > > >> > >> > certainly > > >> > >> > can't hurt to try. > > >> > >> > > > >> > >> > Al > > >> > >> > > > >> > >> > On Mon, 2010-11-15 at 15:29 -0800, Peter Selby wrote: > > >> > >> >> Hi guys, > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >> I'm trying to configure the BMC on an HP ProLiant DL145 G2 using > > >> > >> >> bmc-config. IPMI over LAN is not working; it should have a > > >> > >> >> fixed IP, > > >> > >> >> but it won't respond to anything. > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >> When I try to dump the BMC config, I get: > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >> $ bmc-config --checkout > > >> > >> >> ... > > >> > >> >> Section Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege > > >> > >> >> fiid_obj_get: maximum_privilege_for_cipher_suite_3: no data set > > >> > >> >> $ > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >> Everything prior to that dumps okay. Adding the section (and > > >> > >> >> subsequent SOL_Conf section) manually, I get two possible > > >> > >> >> results: > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >> * Empty Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege: Config commits successfully, > > >> > >> >> but a > > >> > >> >> checkout results in the same problem > > >> > >> >> * Rmcpplus_Conf_Privilege filled in based on the bmc-config.conf > > >> > >> >> manpage (with Maximum_Privilege_Cipher_Suite_Id_0-through-4 or > > >> > >> >> 12): I > > >> > >> >> get the same error, fiid_obj_get: > > >> > >> >> maximum_privilege_for_cipher_suite_3: no data set > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >> Any idea what could be wrong, or how to fix it? And could this > > >> > >> >> be the > > >> > >> >> reason the network won't come up? > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >> Thanks, > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >> Peter > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >> _______________________________________________ > > >> > >> >> Freeipmi-devel mailing list > > >> > >> >> [email protected] > > >> > >> >> http://BLOCKEDBLOCKEDBLOCKEDBLOCKEDBLOCKEDlists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/freeipmi-devel > > >> > >> >> > > >> > >> > -- > > >> > >> > Albert Chu > > >> > >> > [email protected] > > >> > >> > Computer Scientist > > >> > >> > High Performance Systems Division > > >> > >> > Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory > > >> > >> > > > >> > >> > > > >> > >> > > >> > > -- > > >> > > Albert Chu > > >> > > [email protected] > > >> > > Computer Scientist > > >> > > High Performance Systems Division > > >> > > Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory > > >> > > > > >> > > > > >> -- > > >> Albert Chu > > >> [email protected] > > >> Computer Scientist > > >> High Performance Systems Division > > >> Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory > > >> > > >> > > >> _______________________________________________ > > >> Freeipmi-devel mailing list > > >> [email protected] > > >> http://BLOCKEDBLOCKEDlists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/freeipmi-devel > > >> > > > -- > > > Albert Chu > > > [email protected] > > > Computer Scientist > > > High Performance Systems Division > > > Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory > > > > > > > > -- Albert Chu [email protected] Computer Scientist High Performance Systems Division Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory _______________________________________________ Freeipmi-devel mailing list [email protected] http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/freeipmi-devel
