Julien Schafer (j.schafer) writes:
> Bonjour
>
> Je voudrais savoir si certains ont un avis éclairé sur les solutions
> disponibles sur le marché (sachant qu'il y a du GPL, du payant etc)
J'ai fini par compiler une liste des différents outils, avec des
commentaires perso (en anglais), y compris des outils plus complets
de gestion d'inventaire/configuration/data center.
J'ai pas tout regardé, mais je retiens:
- GestioIP
- Ralph 3
- phpIPAM
- opennetadmin
- nocproject (usine à ga^H^Hplutonium)
- NetDot (que je connais bien)
# IPAM and CMDB software
## IPAM
* HaCi http://haci.larsux.de/ - 2015-03
- IPAM only, v4/v6, multiple POPs, uses templates, space visualization
* GestioIP http://haci.larsux.de/ - 2016-02
- IPAM w/ VLAN management, subnet disco. via SNMP, space visualization
- BIND zone file generator fwd/ptr
- Integration OCS Inventory NG
* TeemIP - http://www.combodo.com/teemip-194 (2015-03), part of iTop or alone
- request management w/portal systen for requestors
- DNS
- extensible
* Subnetsmgt http://sourceforge.net/projects/subnetsmngr/ - 2013-05
- IPAM
- PowerDNS integration
* phpIPAM - http://phpipam.net - 2016-02
VLAN, VRF, visualization, RIPE, host scanning, etc...
IP request form
* netmagis - http://netmagis.org - 2015-09
Split DNS support
DHCP/DNS integration
VLAN maanagement
Generate traffic graphs
## Inventory management / CMDB (possibly including IPAM)
* iTop https://wiki.openitop.org/doku.php - 2014 (w/updates 2016)
- Modular CMDB
- Modules like TeemIP
* Netdot - https://osl.uoregon.edu/redmine/projects/netdot - 2015-01
- great for campus networks
- no overlapping IP/VLAN support - yet!
- no VRF support
- great integration to third party tools
- actively maintained
* Racktables - http://racktables.org/ - 2016-02 - active
- Rack/DC specific (objects / IP / vlan / asset tags)
- no built-in DNS integration
* glpi - http://www.glpi-project.org - 2016-04 - active
- Full fledged asset/inventory management
- Modular, including Puppet integration
- ITILish
* OCS inventory-ng
- Inventory / deployment
- Integrates with GLPI
- Lots of typos on website...
- Download requires filling out a form, but it's on github
* Ralph 3 - http://allegro.tech/ralph/ - 2016 - active
- rack/asset mgmt
- rack visualization
- review
http://blog.admin-linux.org/pilotage/ralph-systeme-de-gestion-d-actifs-pour-datacenter-cmdb-dcim
* OpenDCIM - http://www.opendcim.org/ -
- DC physical inventory
- multi site support
- calculate center of gravity for rack (!)
- PDU integration
* opennetadmin http://opennetadmin.com - 2016-03 - active
- modular
- support for hooks/host actions
- config. backup
- VLAN, etc.
- CLI for interacting with system
- DNS view support
* nocproject - https://kb.nocproject.org/display/SITE/NOC - 2015-05 / active
- this thing is in another class - it does *everything*,
from configuration management to outage planning to
inventory, provisioning, etc... 50 vendors+ supported
- around for some years, written by Russians with
some documentation in English, and even more in Russian
- 120 people on the Telegram chat room!
- for the new version, they built a deployment system called
"Tower" just to manage Noc installations, based around ansible:
https://bitbucket.org/nocproject/noc-tower
* cmbuild http://www.cmdbuild.org/en/prodotti/cmdbuild - 2016-06 / active
- this is a toolkit for building your own ITIL compliant
CMDB
- probably overkill for anyone
Others:
* tipp - https://github.com/tobez/tipp - 2014
- IPAM and only IPAM
- In production for some years
* ipplan (iptrack) http://iptrack.sourceforge.net/ - 2010
- dead ?
- v6 support added later
---------------------------
Liste de diffusion du FRnOG
http://www.frnog.org/
