Keith,
yesterday’s Washington Post or NYT on the Red Sea airplane crash mentioned this
was the third Boeing downed in the Middle East in the last six months or so;
thereby at least trying to make the case this was mechanical failure. All we saw on the television here were
shots of planes taking off from Heathrow for the US, sending the message that “all
is clear”, with no mention of any possible assassination link. However, there
was good coverage of the numerous attempts on Pakistan’s PM, further
reinforcing the imagery that things are safe where the US is involved and
proactive but not where we do not have bases and/or allies (West is good/safe vs
Mid-and Near East are bad/not safe).
Today’s NYT
piece mentioned that this was the second visit by Blair to Iraq, one in May before
Bush in November, and Spain’s PM made one in late December. I agree with you that there is too much
coincidence not to be suspicious about the possibility of an assassination attempt.
But I must
disagree that there were not other options at the West’s disposal, to reversing
the course of despotism and fundamentalist theocracies, including building academic
and cultural ties, but which had to begin
with a genuine and ongoing commitment to peace in Israel and Palestine with a
mediated and internationally-supported agreement. This was the harder task, one which the ADD-prone Bush
administration chose to avoid.
Intent and personality
matter. Add that to the presumption that one is destined to take command, as
the Bushies believed, and the Supremes sanctified, and you have a potent
imperial personality capable of launching missions without as much thought to
consequences as others less anointed would dare.
It’s a little
bit like a comment I heard yesterday in regard to the safety of US beef. The
political pundit remarked that she would feel much better hearing declarative
statements such as “I just ate beef today” and “its’ perfectly safe” from a vegetarian, rather than a beef-eating
Texan -- who had already told us several
fibs on other significant issues regarding national security and the public
health (italicized phrase is mine).
Now is the
time all those who worked against the corporate lobby that suppressed better
inspections and processing standards to come forth and say I told you so. Now is the time for politicians
and those who carry the burden of protecting us on our borders, in our
airports, overseas, to step forward and say ‘there’s got to be a better way to
accomplish’ this mission rather by the means we have begun it. Before we are committed any further,
now is the time for those same citizens who accepted in good faith that their
leaders would not lie to them about so serious a charge to demand
accountability.
-KWC
243. Attempted assassination of Tony Blair?
Politicians and government spokesmen have a certain manner when defusing news
that disconcerts them -- a slight shrugging of the shoulders, a dismissive
smile, a brief statement and then a quick disappearance from the interviewer's
camera.
This is what happened yesterday when the report came through that an airplane
had plunged into the Red Sea killing 148 French tourists. "Oh, it wasn't
an Al Qaeda attack", was the response of several. "We have no evidence
to think it was."
Really? It was only the previous day that the American CIA were publicizing the
fact that there had been an increase in mobile phone and Internet traffic of
the sort that usually preceded Al Qaeda attacks -- and that this was the reason
why they were holding up certain flights to the US.
Well, I can thoroughly understand and sympathise with the Egyptian government
spokesman. Their tourist trade was severely set back by the terrorist incident
at Luxor some years ago, and the latest incident will set back their tourist
trade a few more years no doubt. He had to make it seem that it was just
another airplane accident that could have happened anywhere.
The New York Times didn't give it a front-page headline and even the BBC website
went along with what can only amount to camouflage. Last night, the following
was all there was :
<<<<
An Egyptian charter plane belonging to Flash Airlines crashes into the Red Sea,
killing all 141 people on board. Most of the passengers are thought to be
French tourists. 3 January 2004
>>>>
There was not a word that the airplane had taken off from Sharm el-Sheik airport,
and not a word that Tony Blair and family were on holiday at Sharm el-Sheik,
and not a word that Tony Blair and family would be flying back to the UK any
day now from the same airport.
It stretches credulity too far to imagine that the loss of the airplane was anything
other than an attempted assassination on Tony Blair. (I wouldn't mind betting
-- though we shall possibly never know -- that Tony Blair was, in fact, due to
go on the next flight to the UK from Sharm el-Sheik, or at least soon
afterwards, and that Al Qaeda got their information slightly wrong. Or perhaps
it was intended as a coded warning to Blair, albeit at the expense of French
lives.) (P.S. The very latest news this morning which I've heard a few minutes
ago on the radio just before posting this is that Tony Blair has now magically
appeared in Basra, Iraq! This is further confirmation to my mind that western
governments will do and say anything to disguise what was undoubtedly an
assassination attempt.)
Where does all this take us? In particular, where does it take America and the
UK? It means that the invasion of Iraq has now stirred up a hornet's nest that
was already active in Saudi Arabia. As long as American troops are in Iraq, Al
Qaeda and the Wahhabi clerics of Saudi Arabia will be assisting their cousins,
the Sunni extremists in Baghdad, in whatever way they can. And the Wahhabis and
Sunnis will continue to have the support of traditionalist elements with
the Saudi royal family which oppose the reformist attempts of Crown Prince
Abdullah, the formal president.
Unless Crown Prince Abdullah acts very soon and puts Prince Nayef (see Posting
141) under lock and key, together with several hundred other members of the
royal family (6,000 in all) who support the Wahhabi establishment then the
Saudi Arabia government must be considered to be the most potentially unstable
of any in the world. I imagine that a revolution or palace insurrection can be
far away now.
Something went seriously awry in the world of Islam at around the 13th and 14th
centuries when their clerics started to turn their backs on European science.
And yet, previously, Islamic philosophers were ahead of anybody else in the
whole world, even the Chinese. All the way down the west coast of north Afirca,
there are ancient cities that still have libraries of beautiful Arabic
manuscripts of the 10th and 11th centuries concerning mathematics and astronomy
and other sciences. There are drawings in profusion of the solar system which
preceded Copernicus' ideas by two centuries. (See Michael Palin's book,
Sahara.)
I considered that the invasion of Iraq was a seriously irresponsible event. Nevertheless,
I can't lay my hands easily on what should have been done otherwise. In Islam
there is, unfortunately, a whole culture that has, since the 13th and 14th
century, become set against any form of free enquiry -- and indeed basic
freedom for their populations. The result is that in the Islamic countries,
such as Pakistan, Iran, Iraq and Saudi Arabia, there are seething masses of
oppressed people, particularly excessive numbers of young people without jobs,
who have nothing to do except explode in anger and frustration.
All I can suggest is that the American aircraft carriers which are
situated all around the Gulf should be turned into universities, and that the
tanks patrolling the streets of Baghad should be turned into mobile
schoolrooms. We should not be sending soldiers to the Middle East but teachers.
But this is a forlorn dream. I'm afraid that we will see nothing but increasing
warfare and bloodshed in the Middle East until the Big Powers (I will leave them
nameless) have secured Middle East oil and gas supplies for their use for as
long as the resources will last.
Keith Hudson
Keith Hudson, Bath, England, <www.evolutionary-economics.org>
_______________________________________________
Futurework mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://fes.uwaterloo.ca/mailman/listinfo/futurework