The proposed Robin Hood Tax is not only long overdue, it is simply inadequate--far below public consumer tax levels, and is token emotional restitution to quiet the masses. It may be well intended, but it is far removed from a strong position, and in its timorous approach, still pays deference to the white collar crooks.

Something like $15 trillion went into the bailout, and it has only kept the biggest banks/investment firms from bankruptcy. The average mortgage holder got about 7% of their entitlement, and the funds that went to municipal and state treasuries to ease regional strife were largely misappropriated for corporate development, not social agencies or relief, because of the loosely worded terms of allocation.

So when they propose a Robin Hood Tax, it sounds like the next great external solution, but if one reviews the list of all it could address, $350 billion/year isn't going to stretch much beyond a few projects of national scale. They're not being at all specific about what the pool would finance, which, knowing government and its corporate minions, would probably leave the sum open to indeterminate future needs.

Well, what's more important than saving the financial sector, /again/? Most of these $ trillions were there all along, could have been helping neglected citizens and the international community through the years, but the revelation that the US market was about to collapse was the sole motivator for government (and Federal Reserve) action.

Investors can certainly afford the puny sum of up to 50 cents per $100. The things I see holding them back, apart from the dismal state of the markets and the waiting game over the right currency trades, are even cheaper real estate to come, more widespread privatization of resources, and fears around how to weather the possible collapse of major currencies, led by the US, China or the E.U..

We've all been observing the amounts of gold hoarding going on by major banks and investment firms. They know that something is going down, and want the security of liquid assets.

I wonder just how many investors are waiting for pre- Dec. 21st sell-offs? No doubt many investors will try and cash in, before and after. Food and water sales are up, survival gear, arms, communications, and such. Perhaps that's it? They're waiting to take advantage of the fears of everyone who believes something big will happen on 12/21/12.

*Natalia*

On 19/09/2012 1:54 PM, pete wrote:
The stock market in the US is currently in a state of deep disrepute
with the public, after all the revelations of self serving manipulation
by the formerly respected behemoths of the financial industry, as you
read in the comments of Sandy Lewis posted here a few days ago. Add
to that the devastated US economy, courtesy of the same fine collection
of individuals, and there's nothing to invest even if one was inclined.
Thus the rehabilitation of its reputation is at least as urgent as
any other form of resuscitation, and would outweigh any negative
impact on its function. In fact, any kind of trade which is discouraged
by such a tax is exactly the sort that shouldn't be going on in the
first place, so their cessation will immediately improve the general
health of the market. "We can't do that because it will interfere with
the free flow of commerce" is just a facile diversion which has been
used too many times to justify far too many abuses, and it needs to
end if we are ever going to achieve a society whose financial system
is its servant, not its master.

  -Pete




On Wed, 19 Sep 2012, Keith Hudson wrote:

The Robin Hood and other associated taxes on finance are all very well so long
as they're not instituted anytime soon -- despite all the wonderful benefits
that are proposed for them. The whole financial sector of America and the West
is grinding to a halt. Activity on the New York Stock Exchange is about a
quarter of what it used to be, and has been so for months. Traders are playing
dominoes and doing crosswords for lack of something to do. Banks (and more
recently investment banks) are shedding staff. Shed loads of Bernanke's QE
money, instead of getting into consumers' hands (a la Keynes' mid-life views,
but not his very early or very late ones), is all being absorbed by the banks
which, for now and for the next ten years at least, are monetizing the
collateral "assets" on their books, as also redeeming the riskier derivatives
on which they've spent colossal amounts of money in the last few years, as
also having to buy US bonds (at near negative rates of interest) in order to
build up reserves towards the safe levels proposed by the Bank of
International Settlements (the world's "central bank of central banks").

Japan and Western Europe are already creeping into recession; America is
dawdling on the edge. Robin Hood and Co  would only precipitate a deeper and
longer economic depression than the one we are probably destined for anyway.

Keith


  At 06:26 19/09/2012, Mike G wrote:


-----Original Message-----
From: Portside Moderator [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 4:49 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: [SPAM] Robin Hood Tax Bill Introduced In Congress

Robin Hood Tax Bill Introduced In Congress

     HR-6411: To Tax Wall Street; Real Revenue for Critical
     National, International Needs

The Robin Hood Tax
September 17, 2012

http://robinhoodtax.org/latest

New York

The U.S. Robin Hood Tax Campaign today applauded the introduction in
Congress of a bill that would impose a tax on Wall Street speculation.
Introduced by Rep. Keith Ellison, HR 6411, the Inclusive Prosperity Act,
would raise up to $350 billion in annual revenues that would be used to
breathe new life into Main Street communities across America, as well as
international health, sustainable prosperity and environmental programs.

The legislation embodies the Robin Hood Tax, a 0.5% tax on the trading of
stocks, 50 cents on every $100 of trades, and lesser rates on trading in
bonds, derivatives and currencies.
It marks the return of a sales tax on financial transactions in place from
1914 to 1966 and targets the high-risk, high- speed trading that dominates
the markets.

  "The American public provided hundreds of billions to  bailout Wall Street
during the global fiscal crisis yet bore  the brunt of the crisis with lost
jobs and reduced household  wealth," said Rep. Ellison in a press statement.
"This is a  phenomenally wealthy nation, yet our tax and regulatory  system
allowed the financial titans to amass great riches  while impoverishing the
systems that enable inclusive  prosperity. A financial transaction tax
protects our  financial markets from speculation and provides the revenue
needed to invest in the education, health and communities of  the American
people."

The legislation's goal is to raise meaningful tax revenue dedicated to low-
and moderate-income families by strengthening the social safety net and by
expanding investments to protect health, rebuilding infrastructure and
creating good-paying jobs.  The tax is also to target international needs,
including AIDS treatment, research and prevention and for other critical
assistance.

  "Congressman Ellison is showing great leadership for our  country," said
Jean Ross, RN, co-president of National  Nurses United. "HR-6411 is a
critical step to generate the  revenue for the healing and recovery our Main
Street  communities across the nation so desperately need.  From  coast to
coast, nurses, health care, AIDS, environmental,  labor, faith community and
other community activists have  come together calling for a Robin Hood tax
on financial  speculation so that Wall Street will help pay to reverse the
damage its reckless behavior caused to our economy. This is  a small, common
sense tax, already in place and working  wonderfully well in dozens of
countries across the world.
  America is ready for the Robin Hood tax."

  "Last summer, scientists proved that we can actually end the  AIDS pandemic
if we just scale up our investment in  treatment and prevention programs,"
said Jennifer Flynn,  managing director of Health GAP (Global Access
Project).
  "But when we go to Congress, all we hear about are budget  cuts.  We need
to increase revenue and the Robin Hood Tax is  the best of all proposals to
do just that."

"This tiny tax on Wall Street will make our economy more stable and more
fair.  The U.S. once had a Robin Hood Tax and we were better off for it,
it's time to bring it back," said Liz Ryan Murray, policy director for
National People's Action.

"In its essentials, the idea of a financial market transaction tax is
simple," said economist Robert Pollin, co- director, Political Economy
Research Institute (PERI), University of Massachusetts- Amherst.  "It would
mean that financial market traders would pay a small fee to the government
every time they purchased any financial market instrument, including all
stock, bond, options, futures, and swap trades.  This would be the
equivalent of sales taxes that Americans have long paid every time they buy
an automobile, shirt, baseball glove, airline ticket, or pack of chewing
gum, eat at a restaurant, or have their hair cut."

The Robin Hood Tax also helps to control the volume of speculation engulfing
the financial markets, where risky bets are causing instability and
sidelining billions in funds that might otherwise be directed to a
productive economy.  And the sales tax assists in curtailing speculation in
food and fuel markets, where bets on these essentials are causing spikes in
prices and serious shortages.

The introduction of H.R. 6411 came on the eve of the One Year Anniversary of
Occupy Wall Street. Occupy's call to stop the policies of inequality of the
1% continues to resonate across this country and beyond.  Robin Hood Tax
campaigners today joined Occupy activists at a labor solidarity event at
Zuccotti Park in New York City, and then carried the message to offices of
financial institutions to demand imposition of the Robin Hood Tax.

___________________________________________

Portside aims to provide material of interest to people on the left that
will help them to interpret the world and to change it.

Submit via email: [email protected]

Submit via the Web: http://portside.org/submittous3

Frequently asked questions: http://portside.org/faq

Sub/Unsub: http://portside.org/subscribe-and-unsubscribe

Search Portside archives: http://portside.org/archive

Contribute to Portside: https://portside.org/donate


!DSPAM:2676,505926c725481638912135!

_______________________________________________
Futurework mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.uwaterloo.ca/mailman/listinfo/futurework
Keith Hudson, Saltford, England http://allisstatus.wordpress.com
_______________________________________________
Futurework mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.uwaterloo.ca/mailman/listinfo/futurework


_______________________________________________
Futurework mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.uwaterloo.ca/mailman/listinfo/futurework

Reply via email to