No, it do not work after changing it from "encoded" to "literal". I only could create java classes with wsimport [1] after changing it. A teammate also told me to change it to "literal" for Microsoft Dynamics AX because he is already consuming soap services and they all use "literal".
The problem I have is, that I wrote an application and now I need a soap service to provide functionality to non-php-applications. We begun to test the soap service with Microsoft Dynamics AX but it won´t work. After I could not figure out why (useless error messages, no possibility to check what the service is doing) we tried to consume the service with an java soap client. There I got usefull error messages so I could change Zend_Soap_AutoDiscover like mentioned in my first email. Now I could create java classes with wsimport to consume the soap service but I always get NULL as return value. No error message, no empty result... only NULL. Found another application that can consume the soap service. WSDL explorer of WTP project (http://www.eclipse.org/webtools/). Don´t know what it is written in, but I think it is writtn in java like all eclipse plugins :-) [1] https://jax-ws.dev.java.net/jax-ws-ea3/docs/wsimport.html -- Jan > this is very valueable input. thank you very much. > > I have to look into that. Unfortunatly the AutoDiscover and WSDL internals > are > in very bad shape to extend without easily breaking backwards compability, so > i cannot assure you that I can include it in the next mini or minor release. > > Do i understand you correctly, that it worked for you with Java, when you > switched from encoded to literal? > > greeetings > Benjamin > > On Tuesday 25 November 2008 21:23:30 Jan Pieper wrote: >> Hi guys, >> >> I created a small soap service with Zend_Soap_Server and >> Zend_Soap_AutoDiscover but I cannot consume its data via a java soap >> client. I tried it all the day but it won´t work. >> >> ----- SNIP ----- >> >> class MyFooService >> { >> /** >> * @return string >> */ >> public function getStaticString() { >> return 'Hello World'; >> } >> } >> >> ----- SNAP ----- >> >> It is accessable (for me!) via http://jason/Laboratory/JMS/service.php >> which is the service and http://jason/Laboratory/JMS/service.php?wsdl which >> will show wsdl definition. The created wsdl definition looks like this: >> >> ----- SNIP ----- >> >> <?xml version="1.0"?> >> <definitions xmlns="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/"; >> xmlns:tns="http://jason/Laboratory/JMS/service.php"; >> xmlns:soap="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/soap/"; >> xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"; >> xmlns:soap-enc="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/encoding/"; >> xmlns:wsdl="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/"; >> name="MyFooService" >> targetNamespace="http://jason/Laboratory/JMS/service.php";> <portType >> name="MyFooServicePort"> >> <operation name="getStaticString"> >> <input message="tns:getStaticStringRequest" /> >> <output message="tns:getStaticStringResponse" /> >> </operation> >> </portType> >> <binding name="MyFooServiceBinding" type="tns:MyFooServicePort"> >> <soap:binding style="rpc" >> transport="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/http"; /> >> <operation name="getStaticString"> >> <soap:operation >> >> soapAction="http://jason/Laboratory/JMS/service.php#getStaticString"; /> >> <input> >> <soap:body use="literal" >> namespace="http://jason/Laboratory/JMS/service.php"; /> >> </input> >> <output> >> <soap:body use="literal" >> namespace="http://jason/Laboratory/JMS/service.php"; /> >> </output> >> </operation> >> </binding> >> <service name="MyFooServiceService"> >> <port name="MyFooServicePort" binding="tns:MyFooServiceBinding"> >> <soap:address >> location="http://jason/Laboratory/JMS/service.php"; /> </port> >> </service> >> <message name="getStaticStringRequest" /> >> <message name="getStaticStringResponse"> >> <part name="getStaticStringReturn" type="xsd:string" /> >> </message> >> </definitions> >> >> ----- SNAP ----- >> >> As you can see I do not use Zend_Soap_AutoDiscover in its original version >> (see attached MyAutoDiscover.diff, could not extend and use my own class >> because I need access to private class properties). I needed to change >> <soap:body use="encoded" encodingStyle="..." /> to <soap:body use="literal" >> namespace="..." /> because wsimport (small tool included in jdk) cannot >> handle "encoded". So I used following command to create java classes from >> wsdl definiton: >> >> # wsimport -keep http://jason/Laboratory/JMS/service.php?wsdl >> >> So I got this two java classes: >> >> # jason.laboratory.jms.service.MyFooServicePort.java >> # jason.laboratory.jms.service.MyFooServiceService.java >> >> After that I created a soap client using these classes (jdk1.6.0_10): >> >> ----- SNIP ----- >> >> package jason.laboratory.jms.myfooclient; >> >> import jason.laboratory.jms.service.*; >> >> public class MyFooClient >> { >> /** >> * @param args >> */ >> public static void main(String[] args) >> { >> MyFooServiceService mfss = new MyFooServiceService(); >> MyFooServicePort mfsp = mfss.getMyFooServicePort(); >> String result = mfsp.getStaticString(); >> >> if (result != null) { >> System.out.println("Result: " + result); >> } else { >> System.out.println("Result is NULL"); >> } >> } >> } >> >> ----- SNAP ----- >> >> I expected "Result: Hello World" but I always get "Result is NULL". >> Zend_Soap_Client has no problems consuming the service. >> >> It looks like an java problem, but we also tested the same soap server >> using a Microsoft Dynamics AX soap client and got the same result. Okay we >> do not get "NULL" as return value from service, the Microsoft soap client >> shows "1" as result. >> >> So I am searching for a solution how to get it working. I am absolutly >> clueless why I do not get the correct result. Is there someone who can >> verify or solve my problem? :-) >> >> If there are any questions or if there are more information needed, please >> ask! If needed I can upload my sources. >> >> -- Jan >
