Hello Leandro,

I've forwarded your request to the galaxy-dev mail list as this is where issues 
like this are discussed.

I want to make sure I'm clear on this issue.  Can you provide some 

On Apr 11, 2012, at 5:05 AM, Leandro Hermida wrote:

> Based on our initial use of the sample tracking system I haven't found
> any additional bugs, but we did realize one big functionality that is
> missing which makes the system somewhat hard to use.
> The current mechanism to link datasets to their corresponding samples
> is very cumbersome and takes a long time as it has to be done one
> sample at a time with a lot of UI clicking and there is a big
> potential for human error.  I would say without an easier way to do
> this it would detract people from using the sample tracking system. Do
> you have any ideas to change/enhance the way this is done?

The current UI is something that we have plans to improve - the underlying 
framework is flexible and allows for improvement in several areas.  We will 
certainly consider any recommendations from the community, including yours 

> My initial
> suggestion would be that when you upload the samples using a CSV file
> that you can have a field like "DatasetsName" after FolderName where
> you can have a colon (:) separated list of file paths from the
> configured external service? That would solve it I think and make
> things much easier.

I've pasted an example screenshot below for reference.  At the point that you 
are importing samples from a CSV file, the sequence run is not yet started 
(generally speaking), so there are no sequence run datasets (file names) yet 
produced.  So in order to create the csv file with the correct sequence run 
file names, the user will have to know beforehand the resulting files produced 
by the sequencer.  Will this always be possible with your "Illumina external 
service"?  If so, what are the names of the files, and how are they 
distinguished between runs?  Do they just go in different directories in the 
sequencer that are also know beforehand?

On the other hand, are you saying that your lab will perform the sequence run 
and wait until the run is complete and the datasets are produced and then 
create the csv file, entering the known dataset file names to produce the 
sample line items for the sequencing request?  The weakness of this process is 
that your lab's customers will not be able to use Galaxy sample tracking to 
view the status of their requests throughout their lifecycle since the 
request's sample line items will not be created until the run is finished.  

I'll work on implementing this enhancement, but I want to understand how you're 
lab will use it.  Any additional information you can provide will be helpful.



Add samples to sequencing request "one"

Name    State   Data Library    Folder  History Workflow        

For each sample, select the data library and folder in which you would like the 
run datasets deposited. To automatically run a workflow on run datastets, 
select a history first and then the desired workflow.
 Layout Grid1

 Sample form layout 1

Copy  samples from sample 
Select the sample from which the new sample should be copied or leave selection 
as None to add a new "generic" sample.

Click the Add sample button for each new sample and click the Save button when 
you have finished adding samples.
Import samples from csv file

The csv file must be in the following format.
The [:FieldValue] is optional, the named form field will contain the value 
after the ':' if included.
Please keep all replies on the list by using "reply all"
in your mail client.  To manage your subscriptions to this
and other Galaxy lists, please use the interface at:


Reply via email to