Hi Dark,

Shrug. I looked this up on Wikipedia, and according to Wikipedia the
guy who created the show back in the 1960's was flying somewhere with
his wife when they decided to play a trivia game. While playing his
wife said why not reverse the question and answer. She suggested
giving the contestant the clue and see if they could come up with the
correct answer. He thought that was an interesting idea, and decided
to pass the idea on to his boss at NBC. Turned out NBC liked the idea,
and that's how Jeopardy came to be.

At any rate since the show has been around since the 1960's, before I
was even born, naturally Jeopardy wouldn't be Jeopardy if it were any
other way. It doesn't matter to me if it makes sense or not. that's
just the way it is. No debate needed.

Of course, I sort of see your point of view here. You didn't grow up
with the show, didn't have the experience I did sitting around the TV
at night playing the game with your family with the show, and
therefore there is no sentimental attachment to the show. You are an
outsider coming at this from an outside perspective and asking a lot
of questions like why do this or why do that when most Americans like
myself just accept the rules of the game as is. After all the rules
are the rules, and nobody here questions them.

Another way to look at this is let's say you came to America and
watched a football game. Now, the rules are if a player reaches the
end zone without being tackled his team is awarded 6 points for a
touchdown. The kicker can then come out and try and kick an extra
point by kicking the ball through the goal post.  Let's suppose you
think since a standard field goal is 3 points rather than kicking for
an extra point you think the team should get the full three points for
putting the ball through the goal post after a touchdown. there would
be plenty of American football fans willing to kick you through the
goal post by the seat of your pants for suggesting such a thing as
that would change the rules of the game. :D

In other words what I'm saying is you are trying to rationalize
something that doesn't need rationalized. It doesn't have to make
sense or serve any particular point other than that's the way the
creator of the show decided to do it. It just is the way it is and
most people accepts it that way.

Cheers!




On 5/27/12, dark <[email protected]> wrote:
> Hi Tom.
>
> I can appreciate the obscurity of questions certainly, indeed that was often
>
> why I watched quiz shows myself, and why I get so irritated with the modern
>
> ones, ---- for instance I saw a recent game show just before I stopped my tv
>
> license which had a round in which players had to memorize a sequence of
> first 4, then 5 then an entire 6! flashing lights, ---- oooo no! how tricky.
>
> However, the Jeopardy reverse logic thing is still something I really don't
>
> see the point of, sinse it doesn't strike me as so different saying "what is
>
> an ovum" to use your example, as just "ovum"
>
> to me, it's like simon says or other party games involving rythm and
> numbers, just inserting some random words before your answer to make it a
> question, but not actually changing the content of the question and answer
> all that much.
>
> Perhaps however sinse the british version was obviously less than
> successful, and it never court on after that (I only used to watch it
> because Bbc2 showed it just before the reruns of the Buck rogers tv series),
>
> this is something more of a cultural thing that you had to grow up watching,
>
> with the hosts' personality and quality of the catagories playing a part in
>
> why it had appeal.
>
>
> After all, who wants to be a millionare is at rock bottom a multiple choice
>
> exercize, and thus quite dull if described as a quiz, and while they did get
>
> to some obscure questions later on, you had to get far along for those.
> Ultimately as much of the appeal was watching some greedy person risk
> everything on one answer, then watching Chris tarrant taunt them silly by
> taking as long as possible to actually tell people whether they were right
> or not.
>
> ditto with the wonderfuly creative insults by Anne robinson on the weakest
> link.
>
> Beware the grue!
>
> Dark.

---
Gamers mailing list __ [email protected]
If you want to leave the list, send E-mail to [email protected].
You can make changes or update your subscription via the web, at
http://mail.audyssey.org/mailman/listinfo/gamers_audyssey.org.
All messages are archived and can be searched and read at
http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected].
If you have any questions or concerns regarding the management of the list,
please send E-mail to [email protected].

Reply via email to