https://english.pravda.ru/society/92157-dzerzhinsky/

(Updated: 20.02.2021 20:06)
Lubyanka monument controversy: Felix Dzerzhinsky or Alexander Nevsky?

Society  <https://english.pravda.ru/society/>» Real life stories
<https://english.pravda.ru/society/stories/>

The Russians are going to vote to decide the fate of the monument on
Moscow's Lubyanka Square, opposite the former KGB headquarters (currently
FSB).

*https://youtu.be/7aphbXjyuAk <https://youtu.be/7aphbXjyuAk>*
Felix Dzerzhinsky or Alexander Nevsky?

>From February 25 to March 5, 2021, the Active Citizen website will hold a
vote regarding the monument on Lubyanka Square in Moscow.

The background of the story is as follows. In December 2020, Officers of
Russia organisation  appealed to Prosecutor General Igor Krasnov with a
request to evaluate the legality of the demolition of the monument to Felix
Dzerzhinsky. The monument by Yevgeny Vuchetich was dismantled on the square
after the failure of the August putsch in 1991. The public organization
initiated the procedure to return the monument to Lubyanka (the monument is
currently located in Muzeon Park).

On February 19, members of the Council of the Public Chamber of Moscow
supported the the idea of the survey among Muscovites to find out their
opinion about which historical persona should be dominant on Lubyanka
Square. Representatives of the Moscow administration told TASS that they
were ready to consider this proposal.

wo personalities were offered to choose from: Felix Dzerzhinsky and
Alexander Nevsky (a proposal from the museum community), Public Chamber
chairman Konstantin Remchukov said. No one offered the "fountain" that had
been the centrepiece of the square until 1936.

"We decided that the purity of the genre is as follows: we received two
proposals, and we are submitting these two proposals for discussion.
Otherwise, we do not have a mechanism to pick other candidates," he said

According to Remchukov, responses received from all 146 Moscow
municipalities will be studied, and the results of the survey will be
forwarded to the mayor's office.

"When the Moscow City Duma votes, the authorities will have reasons to make
decisions based on, as we hope, a slightly more accurate picture of the
opinion of Muscovites."

We would like to point out two things:

   - it's good that they decided to ask Muscovites;
   - secondly, this is a political issue that needs to be resolved once and
   for all.


Читайте больше на https://english.pravda.ru/society/92157-dzerzhinsky/
Alexander Nevsky is not good for Moscow

Many Russians, especially Muscovites, associate Alexander Nevsky with St.
Petersburg. Given the bitter rivalry between the two capitals, Nevsky is
unlikely to win the vote in Moscow.

It is worthy of note that the discussion about the monument to Prince
Alexander Nevsky is currently being conducted in Nizhny Novgorod (next to
the Alexander Nevsky Cathedral). Five years ago, they discussed the
installation of the monument to Nevsky in Kirov. The authorities supported
the idea then. They even set the opening date - June 12, 2015, but the
project was never implemented. All those initiatives (including the one
regarding Lubyanka Square) came from the Russian Orthodox Church.

The ROC believes that the return of the monument to Dzerzhinsky would be
"an indicator of historical amnesia about the period before 1917," Bishop
Savva (Tutunov), deputy manager of the Moscow Patriarchate, wrote in his
Telegram channel.

In his opinion, "the treatment of *historical amnesia*, which does not
allow to see such a symbol in such prominent men of our country as Ivan III
or, closer to the subject, Benckendorf, would help." The bishop also
pointed out that "Saint Alexander Nevsky could be remembered this year
without difficulty (the year of the 800th anniversary of the prince)."

Nevertheless, he admits that it is not only "fanatics of the Soviet past,"
who advocate the idea of the monument, but also the people who simply "need
a symbol of the harsh and just power of the state.

Dzerzhinsky is not "historical amnesia"

The monument to Felix Dzerzhinsky is historically linked with the iconic
KGB-FSB building on Lubyanka. The people who work there obviously lobby for
the monument to their founder to return.

It was KGB servicemen of middle and lower ranks who did not support the
1991 putsch, although their leader Kryuchkov was a member of the State
Emergency Committee. Kryuchkov was not defending the state, which the
Russian people and the Russian elite had been building for centuries. He
was defending the rotten Soviet nomenklatura system that had lost its
connection with the people.

Therefore, the return of the monument to Dzerzhinsky would put an emphasis
on "clean hands and cold heart", rather than "dictatorship and regime
glorification." This is not "historical amnesia", because the monument to
the repressed - the Solovetsky stone - is located near the KGB/FSB
building, meaning that the lesson of history has been taken into account.

It is worthy of note that it was Dzerzhinsky who issued an arrest warrant
for Lavrentiy Beria for abuse of power in the Azerbaijan Cheka (emergency
committee) in 1921. It was only the intercession of Sergo Ordzhonikidze and
Joseph Stalin that saved Beria.

"Since the mid-1920s, Dzerzhinsky had been actually in opposition to
Stalin, although he was fighting against all oppositionists, trying to
preserve the unity of the party. That was one of the reasons for his
silence at high party forums, but he expressed his opinions in private
letters and conversations. On June 2, 1926, he told Rykov: "I do not share
the policy of this government. I don't understand it nor do I see any point
in it," Doctor of History Alexander Plekhanov wrote.
Dzerzhinsky as a brilliant statesman

Any monument does not mean to glorify and hail an object, for which it is
created. Many Russians still see Dzerzhinsky is a symbol of brilliant
statesmanship.

Dzerzhinsky's merits included:

   - revealing conspiracies of foreign intelligence services and conducting
   a fight against banditry;
   - restoration of infrastructure (People's Commissar of Internal Affairs,
   Railways, Chairman of the Supreme Council of the National Economy),
   - social rehabilitation of children was carried out (one of the tasks of
   the Cheka was to eliminate  homelessness and neglect among children, whose
   parents died during the First World War and the Civil War, intervention,
   hunger, and Entente sanctions.

He was also a member of the Revolutionary Military Council of the Western
Front during the war with the Poles, when Soviet Russia returned part of
the lands of the former Russian Empire. To crown it all, Vladimir Lenin
used to entrust most difficult cases to Dzerzhinsky: "Give it to
Dzerzhinsky. He will do it."

A monument to Dzerzhinsky is not only a monument to him specifically - *this
is a monument to a whole era*. This monument pays tribute to our history,
memory of our fathers and grandfathers who lived and worked to build our
state


Читайте больше на https://english.pravda.ru/society/92157-dzerzhinsky/

-- 
Anda menerima pesan ini karena Anda berlangganan grup "GELORA45" dari Google 
Grup.
Untuk berhenti berlangganan dan berhenti menerima email dari grup ini, kirim 
email ke [email protected].
Untuk melihat diskusi ini di web, kunjungi 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/gelora1945/CAGjSX2Ccg44FrBvHbmQfhum0SR8jotSe0g8zWNjOn_poFgUjug%40mail.gmail.com.

Reply via email to