Forced evictions along Jakarta waterway a liability for Ahok as governor’s 
race nears finish line 
https://news.mongabay.com/2017/02/forced-evictions-along-jakarta-waterway-a-liability-for-ahok-as-governors-race-nears-finish-line/
 13 February 2017  / Edith Koesoemawiria 
https://news.mongabay.com/by/edith-koesoemawiria
 
 The man in charge of Indonesia’s capital region has promised a flood-free 
metropolis by 2020. But what about the people who live by its rivers? 

 
 Flooding is massive problem in Jakarta. And most of its waterways are heavily 
polluted. The capital region's Governor Ahok has tried to address the problem — 
including by demolishing riverside slums. Residents of Bukit Duri, which stood 
on the banks of the Ciliwung River until the government tore it down last year, 
are suing the city in a class-action suit. 

 JAKARTA — Six weeks after the last of the Bukit Duri evictees moved into their 
new dwellings here in the Indonesian capital, the atmosphere was friendly but 
painful. Some tenants told jokes at the food stall in the parking lot. The 
cook, also a former Bukit Duri resident, had initially gone to her hometown of 
Bogor. But after a neighbor told her about the new quarters and a possible 
income, she returned. “I lived in Bukit Duri for more than two decades — when I 
returned to Bogor there was really no one I knew anymore,” she said. “I was 
alone, moping without anyone to talk to. Here I am with friends, I have a life.”
 Twenty of the evicted families — 96 men, women and children — now live in a 
two-storey, 800-square-meter building in South Jakarta’s Kampung Melayu 
neighborhood, about a kilometer from where their houses in Bukit Duri once 
stood. The riverside slum was mowed to the ground last October in the name of 
flood prevention. The Jakarta administration sent bulldozers, guarded by police 
and soldiers, to remove hundreds of families from the area.
 Bukit Duri lay on the banks of the Ciliwung River, which the government is 
trying to “normalize.” The waterway crosses the city and has been made filthy 
by industrial sewage, garbage dumped by urban residents and a failure of city 
maintenance. Only recently, and especially since incumbent Jakarta Governor 
Basuki Tjahaja “Ahok” Purnama took office, have rivers and many parts of the 
capital region been cleaned, in line with his pledge to end corruption and 
solve the city’s awful traffic and floods. The Ciliwung is prone to overflow, 
and the slum neighborhoods lining its edges suffer regular floods. Ahok 
maintains it is irresponsible to let them live that way.
 
https://imgs.mongabay.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2017/02/13050726/3343665803_258615fde2_b.jpg
 A Bukit Duri resident tries to align a plank so he can cross over to another 
hut during a 2009 flood in the neighborhood, which has since been demolished by 
the city government. Photo by Danumurthi Mahendra/Flickr 
https://www.flickr.com/photos/dmahendra/3343665803/in/photolist-66ta5R-66tamp-9A9ykb-BUZZB7-GtBJot-6r7Jef-6g6FnX-9gERtN-q7L6aZ-9gWE7C-pQnMpm-npjH4L-pQp8b2-gmJFWo-q5EW5C-pQkKrZ-q5EW3y-q7AsTz-pQnMko-pQqLwA-q7L684-pQkKhv-q7U5BL-dLsXSX-pQqLDE-q7L6de-q5EWbE-9dLKue-pQkKoH-5GzZ4j-3AVdb8-8MksiH-gzvoJh-8ePXHr-4etUdt-nr3Z4v-nneN6o-BQmajK-Bdae48-CaxJZZ-Bd3mGj-Bp7NLK-BZXCJb-BvuPVj-BXCjTe-BVjRjo-BN2Zj3-BXCkkr-BN2Yg1-Bp7Q7a/
 Bukit Duri residents resisted the eviction. Some did so militantly, others 
through legal channels. Bukit Duri has existed since 1920. Many families have 
lived there for generations.
 Heri, a 57-year-old evictee, was born in Bukit Duri. His grandfather moved 
there during the Dutch colonial era. He welcomed last month’s court verdict 
http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2017/01/06/court-ruling-proves-bukit-duri-eviction-inhumane-agus.html
 declaring the evictions illegal. The panel of judges at the Jakarta State 
Administrative Court had ordered the city to revoke the eviction notice. The 
Ahok administration has appealed the ruling. Like others, Heri is anxious the 
ruling will be overturned.
 Heri has placed his faith in a class-action suit filed by evictees at the 
Central Jakarta District Court. Each family in the class action claims to have 
evidence of land ownership in the emptied area. Their proof ranges from land 
certificates to letters of land appointments, purchase agreements, building-use 
permits and ownership statements. Heri comes to each hearing. Assisted by Bukit 
Duri resident lawyer Vera Soemarwi, the landowners are demanding full 
compensation and damages. “Come what may,” Heri said, “we will appeal unjust 
rulings and claim justice.”
 
https://imgs.mongabay.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2017/02/13051710/3343664901_09be9ccbf1_b.jpg
 A Bukit Duri resident sells used furniture on a bridge in the neighborhood, 
said to belong to locals who lost their homes in the floods. Photo by 
Danumurthi Mahendra/Flickr https://www.flickr.com/photos/dmahendra/3343664901/ 
The grievance rests in large part on how the city carried out the eviction. The 
government expedited the process by using a regulation against disruption of 
public order. Insinuation flew in the media that residents of the Bukit Duri 
slums were illegal in the capital. Exacerbating the perceived injustice, the 
governor stressed that it was a case of relocation instead of eviction.
 In fact, the city administration had prepared several low-budget, 
modern-looking apartments in other parts of Jakarta, and offered Bukit Duri 
residents three months of free lodging. To qualify, one had to show proof of a 
monthly salary and a letter from one’s employer, open an account in the city’s 
Bank DKI and deposit the equivalent of three months rent. Many residents scrape 
by with jobs in the informal economy and could not fulfill the requirements.
 Heri said the cost of living in an apartment is twice that of the private 
rooms in which they now live. Besides the basic rent of 350,000 rupiah ($26) 
there are costs — water, electricity, maintenance and security — which 
altogether amount to a minimum of 800,000 rupiah monthly. The Kampung Melayu 
homes cost 430,000 rupiah per family.
 On top of that, those getting apartments had to sign an agreement forfeiting 
any prospect of compensation. For Heri and those in the class action, this was 
unacceptable. While some residents were readily relocated, accepting the deal 
and expressing no desire to return to Bukit Duri, others who signed on have 
regretted the choice. Other high-rises made available for previous evictions in 
2003-4 have deteriorated into stapled slums.
 
https://imgs.mongabay.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2017/02/13051946/3344501178_f5a68198c3_b.jpg
 A man stands near a dump site on the banks of the Ciliwung River in Bukit 
Duri. The color of the water is muddy brown, shown here as light grey. The 
black liquid oozing out of the sewage is shown here in its real color. Photo by 
Danumurthi Mahendra/Flickr 
https://www.flickr.com/photos/dmahendra/3344501178/in/photolist-66ta5R-66xrFq-66tamp-3xkiEn-3xkiEv-3xkiDp-3xppg7-3xpphb-3xppf9-3xkiD8-3xppgN-3xppeW-3xppfJ-3xkiDR-3xkiDe-GtBJot
 Another thorn in the flesh is the feeling of being lied to and ignored. As 
early as 2003, architect Marcello Sidharta, then a student at Jakarta’s 
Tarumanagara University, made a maquette — a preliminary sketch — of 
river-friendly living quarters for his studies. Sandyawan Sumardi, director of 
Ciliwung Merdeka, an NGO working more than 20 years in the area, presented it 
to city officials in the hope of gaining support for its realization. There was 
no follow up.
 More recently, in 2012, Sumardi together with the Bukit Duri community and 
assisted by academics and practitioners in Jakarta’s Urban Village Forum 
presented environment and community-sensitive housing designs to President Joko 
Widodo, who was then Jakarta’s governor, with Ahok as his deputy. The designs 
were based on local traditions, besides community resilience and knowledge of 
living with rivers. They were favored and approved of by both men. But the city 
never did anything with the plans.
 
https://imgs.mongabay.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/20/2017/02/13052350/25402763171_cfd15acb5d_k.jpg
 Governor Ahok (green shirt) meets with the Australian ambassador (pink shirt) 
at the TransJakarta Bus headquarters in Jakarta. Photo by Timothy Tobing for 
DFAT/Flickr 
https://www.flickr.com/photos/kedubesaustralia/25402763171/in/photolist-JHBHyV-JmGEj9-MQLQhR-Myg4F9-GQeFYs-P55tFL-GQeG3L-hZr4HY-hZrhaE-nfa4cz-EGLgXa-EGKNtn-ENDWpJ-DTeXSN-EGKJKk-EGL9u4-DTeQ5o-DTf29s-ENE4ty-ENDLQJ-EGFo5H-FtE1JN-FvXwst-EGFoBe-P7yh86-HGZLu5-HGZLkY-GQeFTC-NNKKYb-cLwCZh
 In a fast-growing metropolis like Jakarta, eviction is a recurring issue. 
Documentation of problems and effects of previous evictions can be easily 
found. A 2004 Human Rights Watch report on evictions in Teluk Gong, North 
Jakarta, was delivered — with reports from other countries — to the UN Human 
Settlements Programme (UN Habitat), which accordingly adjusted its urban 
planning guidelines.
 In line with the UN’s 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, UN Habitat 
calls for strong and effective leadership, land-use planning, jurisdictional 
coordination, inclusive citizen participation in infrastructure design, and 
efficient financing to help foster urban responses to climate change. Its 2016 
World Cities Report insists on participation and collaboration, inclusivity, 
and recognition of the rights of minorities and vulnerable groups.
 As Bukit Duri evictees and residents move forward with community-based saving 
plans for land ownership, Sumardi is weary of questions asking why these 
progressive designs were not self-implemented earlier. “Where would we get the 
money to do that? We are just a small and relatively poor community. We have 
knowledge, talent and have the will to develop, but we need government support 
and facilitation.”
 
 Jakarta faces gubernatorial elections on Wednesday. Candidates have turned the 
evictions into a politicum. The two candidates running against Ahok promise no 
more evictions, while the incumbent insists they can’t be avoided as the city 
grows. The latter may be true. For many in Jakarta, Ahok is heroic in his drive 
for change. Improvement in administrative services and the reduction of floods 
have been felt by all. He has proven some learning ability on other sensitive 
issues, but will he learn to make leeway for inclusive citizen participation? 
Or will he keep using heavyhanded (eviction) methods? This remains to be seen. 
The governor’s chair is up for grabs.
 

 

Kirim email ke