Hi Lakshminath,
the reason for the "MUST" on multicast is that datagram multicast
distribution is defined in Fibre Channel only for Class 3, so it does
not make any sense to use other Classes for multicast traffic.
Use of other Classes is instead possible for unicast traffic, and for
backward compatibility reasons we don't want to completely close the
door to them (yet).
Coming to the nits you suggested, the two "must" in section 4.8 express
operational requirements, not protocol requirements, and this is the
reason why they are lower case. The "must" in section 2.2 is not a
protocol requirement as well, because section 2.2 is just an overview of
how Fibre Channel operates. If it hurts, it can be replaced by "have to".
The annexes are informative, and all the "must" there just express how
Fibre Channel works, they are not expressing IP over Fibre Channel
protocol requirements. In a similar manner, the two "recommended" occur
in informative sections of the document, and this is why they are lower
case.
Thanks for your review,
Claudio.
Lakshminath Dondeti wrote:
draft-ietf-imss-ip-over-fibre-channel-03.txt is ready for publication.
But, I do have one question.
First, I must admit I don't know a whole lot about this area. The
document is well written and received a good amount of review. However,
I am curious about a collection of MUSTs and SHOULDs and hence the
question(s).
Section 2.3 says "Class 3 is recommended for IPv6, IPv4 and ARP (see
section 4.3)."
Section 4.3 in turn says "The following types of packets MUST be mapped
in Class 3 FC frames:"
That list contains IPv4 multicast/broadcast, IPv6 multicast, and all
control traffic (unicast, broadcast or multicast).
Other IPv6 and IPv4 packets (i.e., unicast IP packets carrying data
traffic) SHOULD be mapped in Class 3 FC frames as well. Support for
reception of IPv4 or IPv6 packets mapped in FC frames of any Class
other than Class 3 is OPTIONAL; receivers MAY ignore them.
My question is why a "MUST" on the multicast and SHOULD on unicast? Is
this for backward compatibility? (I did take a quick look at 2625 and
that seems to allow other classes for unicast: classes 1 and 2 ?).
Nits: There are a couple of instances of the word "recommended." Should
those be "RECOMMENDED?" There are also a couple of instances of "must"
as well.
regards,
Lakshminath
_______________________________________________
Gen-art mailing list
[email protected]
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art