inline:

On Dec 4, 2008, at 3:19 PM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
<trim>



1) There is an inconsistency between the text in 3.1 claiming
"Netids can be up to 2^32 -1 octets in length" and the instructions
in the rest of the document which restrict them to 128 octets.

The XDR encoding for netids allows them to be 2^32-1 bytes long.

That's obviously not feasible for an IANA registry, which is where the
restriction comes in.

From the I-D:
<trim>

Tell me how I can make it clearer?

Perhaps in the sentence that says "2^32-1" you can explicitly say the XDR encoding allows this long length, but this registry will only allow a much shorter length.

<trim>

5) Why are you putting length restrictions on what can go into the
descriptive parts of the registry? (The description and point of
contact)? Where did the limit values you selected come from?

Regarding the latter question I looked at some registries, and these
seemed to be acceptable limits. Regarding the former question, one
has to have limits. What happens if someone submits a 1MB, 1GB, 1TB, etc.
entry?

IANA says "You've got to be kidding".

This hasn't been a problem, and IANA's not going to need this document as a shield to protect against someone trying to do something like that in the future.

I think what you're really after here is guidance to the person making a registration request rather
than setting rules IANA has to enforce.


Thanks for your fast response!

RjS
_______________________________________________
Gen-art mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art

Reply via email to