On Jul 13, 2009, at 8:17 PM, Ben Campbell wrote:
On Jul 13, 2009, at 5:44 PM, Abhay Roy wrote:
Thanks for a quick check.. Comments inline..
On 7/13/2009 2:22 PM, Ben Campbell wrote:
This is an update to my gen-art review of draft-ietf-ospf-manet-
or-01, reflecting version 02 of the same draft.
All of my comments have been addressed except where noted inline.
Thanks!
Ben.
On Dec 23, 2008, at 3:47 PM, Ben Campbell wrote:
I have been selected as the General Area Review Team (Gen-ART)
reviewer for this draft (for background on Gen-ART, please see
http://www.alvestrand.no/ietf/gen/art/gen-art-FAQ.html).
Please resolve these comments along with any other Last Call
comments
you may receive.
Document: draft-ietf-ospf-manet-or-01
Reviewer: Ben Campbell
Review Date: 2008-12-23
IETF LC End Date: 2008-12-24
IESG Telechat date: (if known)
[...]
-- Section 4:
Is the lack of any existing mechanism to authenticate and
authorize nodes to transit packets a show stopper for deployment?
If this was standards track, I would want to see a lot more
here, e.g. some exposition of threat models implied by the
wirelessness, or introduced by the extensions and procedures
described in this draft. (Or rational that there are not any new
threat models) It's probably okay for an experimental RFC to
have less, as I assume we expect to learn such things from
experience. But if any thinking has been done in that direction,
it would be beneficial to document it now.
My comments on this section have been addressed, but the
approach has been to completely replicate the Security
Consideration section (or at least a large part of it ) from
[MDR]. Although the text is attributed, there is no visual
distinction to show where the quote starts and ends (i.e. quote
marks, indents, etc.).
The easiest solution is probably to simply reference the text
from [MDR], rather than quoting it all here.
(I now consider this an editorial comment rather than a
substantive one.)
The chairs thought it will be best to use the same Security
Consideration for all MANET drafts. It's not a 100% quote, since
some references were RFC* in MDR v/s names in OR. Also, it changes
the mention of MDR in the text to OR. So almost identical.
I am happy to remove the quoted text, and just leave the reference
to it, if that makes is clearer.
If it's not identical, then it may make sense to leave it. It would
be helpful to visually identify any exact quoted text, though.
It makes sense to acknowledge the original discussion of OSPF MANET
threats (whether it be the MDR draft or RFC 5449). However, I don't
think we need to worry about there being some replication of the less
than draft two pages of security considerations.
Thanks,
Acee
Nits and editorial comments:
[...]
-- Section 3.1, paragraph 2:
It's not clear to me if the "MAY" constrains protocol, or
constrains future standards work. If the second, it probably
should not use 2119 language.
No change.
I read that paragraph in the last edit, and what it's trying to
say is other interface types could use the features introduced for
this interface type. If that is confusing, I can drop the case to
non 2119 language.
Given that I'm not sure how you would stop them, it probably makes
sense to be non-normative :-)
In particular, it does not put a normative requirement on
implementations of _this_ draft, right?
-- Section 3.3.10: PushBackInterval
Referring sections mention PushbackInterval + jitter. Jitter is
not mentioned here--is propagation delay the same thing in this
context? If so, it would be helpful to be consistent in
terminology.
No change
Jitter is a very well known practice in routing algorithms as a
way to add a small random percentage (say 10%) to a timer. This
section deals with just the definitions of the newly introduced
timers, so it doesn't mention the jitter. It's the application
section which mention the introduced variance in the exact value.
Hope that clears it up.
Jitter is conceptually well known, but can you assume every
implementer will understand what you mean? If they do, will they
pick reasonable ranges of variation? Is it always positive?
Regards,
-Abhay
_______________________________________________
Gen-art mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art