Hi Suresh,
Please resolve these comments along with any other Last Call comments you may receive.
Well, we won't treat these as "any other Last Call comments" as they arrived almost two months after the end of the last call period.
However, we do value your review and thank you for your comments. As the draft is still under revision after Last Call, I will ask the document editor to take them into consideration along the way.
Cheers, Adrian
Summary: This draft is almost ready for publication as Informational RFC but I have a few comments. Minor ===== * Section 2 I think the definition of a P router is not very accurate. It reads "A P router is used to interconnect the PE routers." Isn't it possible that there are multiple P routers on a path between two PE routers e.g. PE--P--P--P--PE * Section 3 -> "Figure 1 depicts the concept of trusted zones within the MPLS/GMPLS framework" Figure 1 does not show the trusted zones at all. It needs to be revised or this sentence needs to be removed. -> In Figure 2 why is CE1 considered an unauthorized neighbor? I can understand why it is untrusted but I do not see why it is unauthorized. * Section 4 "The discussion is limited to those threats that are unique to MPLS/GMPLS networks or that affect MPLS/GMPLS network in unique ways." This is not really true. Most of the attacks described in this document are not specific to MPLS/GMPLS networks at all. Suggest removing this sentence. Editorial ========= Please fix the following typos * Section 7.1.1 s/cryptograpgic/cryptographic/ * Normative References s/EFC 2741/RFC 2747/ Thanks Suresh
_______________________________________________ Gen-art mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art
