(CCs trimmed) Thanks Tobias.
> On a personal comment/addition: > But maybe worth considering is that availability and integrity of sent > reviews is also important: > I noticed that recently some emails to mail-aliases did not get delivered to > the respective lists and therefore reviews and/or answers to reviews might > not be received by the individuals on these lists. > Unfortunately this happens in some random fashion (for the same sender email > and ietf tools aliases within a short time frame, some times it happens some > times it doesn't), without a timely warning (but usually with a failure > message 3-5 days after the email message has been posted). First > investigations may suggest that this could be due to some spam filter or mail > server configuration issues, however other reasons might also apply. > This can obviously impair the quality of the public review process if > individual comments and reviews will not be delivered. I've always felt that the only solution to this issue is a proper system for uploading reviews (all reviews: secdir reviews, gen-art reviews, AD reviews...) to a reliable database. These days, that would really mean integration with the tracker, so that https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-doria-genart-experience/ would give you a tab where all reviews, and responses, could be uploaded and retrieved. This has never seemed to get to the top of the tools list. Regards Brian Carpenter _______________________________________________ Gen-art mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art
