Hrm, thanks for the feedback. I'll investigate the scheme options with Owen/yourself offline.

Patrick

Doug Cutting wrote:
Patrick Hunt wrote:
Perhaps I misunderstood the scope of this discussion - is it general Hadoop or specific to some subset of Hadoop projects? Regardless, at this time the ZooKeeper community would prefer to continue supporting edits on comments.

All Hadoop sub-projects currently share a single Jira permission scheme.

Jira permission schemes are only alterable by Jira-wide administrators I think, and each TLP has only a few of those. Owen & I are I believe the only Jira-wide admins for the Hadoop TLP. So it might be impractical to use a custom permission scheme per subproject.

If the ZooKeeper community wishes, I suppose we might switch ZooKeeper's Jira to the Apache standard permission scheme, which does permit comment editing.

Doug

Reply via email to